15 Of The Best Cookie Exchange Recipes To Whip Up For Your Party (2024)

Cookie exchanges are a blast, and if you are planning to take part in a cookie exchange, you might be looking for the best cookie exchange recipes! Well, you are in luck, I have tons of recipes all for you listed below, so you can find the perfect tried and true recipe to give a go and take to be a part of the exchange. Dazzle your friends with outstanding cookies that stand out from the rest. A cookie exchange is a fun way to try out new cookies, share, and take home lots of tasty cookies for you to enjoy with your family and friends.

15 Of The Best Cookie Exchange Recipes To Whip Up For Your Party (1)

If you are new to the cookie exchange let, me give you the rundown of how it works. You invite a set amount of ladies or gents over to your home for the party. Each person bakes 1 dozen cookies to enjoy while they are at the party and then you make a dozen for each person that is at the party, that they can take home. So if you have 5 people each person would make a total of six dozen cookies. You include a recipe card so that they have the recipe if they choose to make it on their own. Plus learn these cooking baking secrets to get that perfect cookie every single time.

Some items you might consider when being a part of a cookie exchange:

  • Consider packing the cookies for each guest in a plastic container15 Of The Best Cookie Exchange Recipes To Whip Up For Your Party (2), that they can take and have. So you don’t have to worry about them returning it.
  • Buy a cookie scoop15 Of The Best Cookie Exchange Recipes To Whip Up For Your Party (3) so your cookies are all the same size and nice and uniform. This will make them look nice and you will have a better even cook during your batches.
  • Don’t forget to either print out a recipe card and attach to the container or write out a recipe card15 Of The Best Cookie Exchange Recipes To Whip Up For Your Party (4).

Top Cookie Exchange Recipes To Try Out

Raspberry thumbprint cookies are simple to make, and they have raspberry jam in the center for that perfect sweetness to add to the cookie.

Maple Almond ButterCookiesare vegan and dairy free if you know someone who is on a strict diet. You get that rich maple flavor paired with the nutty element in a tender cookie.

Whip up some of these strawberry chocolate chip cookies. They are the perfect mix of strawberry to chocolate, for that indulging cookie taste. Unique, rich, chewy, soft, and addictive.

15 Of The Best Cookie Exchange Recipes To Whip Up For Your Party (5)Brown Sugar Cookies are a bit different than your classic sugar cookie. These cookies are made with brown sugar, so you get that deep element of flavor, and the sprinkles on top just amplify the presentation.

Nutella anything is always a success. Try out this Nutella stuffed peanut butter cookie recipe, where the peanut butter cookie has a nice Nutella surprise waiting.

If you are having a party around the holidays, consider this gingerbread recipe. You get that spicy and soft cookie in a gingerbread shape. These are one of my favorite recipes ever.

15 Of The Best Cookie Exchange Recipes To Whip Up For Your Party (6)

Talk about amazing, check out these pecan pie cookies. They give you that pecan pie flavor but with a cookie base that compliments it perfectly. These are always a huge hit.

Change things up with this carrot cake cookie with a cream cheese frosting. These cookies are rich, sweet, and perfect down to the last crumb.

Check out these thumbprint caramel pecan cookies. You get that moist cookie base that has a filling of nuts, caramel, and chocolate.

15 Of The Best Cookie Exchange Recipes To Whip Up For Your Party (7)

This 4-ingredient red velvet cookie is very easy to make and really tasty. This is a good recipe to use if you may not be a huge baker but want to create a tasty cookie.

Caramel stuffed ginger cookies are unique and can stand out in a room full of cookies. You get that spice from the ginger and sweet from the caramel, that works well together.

Another tasty creation are these soft frosted eggnog cookies. It has more of a sugar cookie base with an eggnog flavored frosting that has you dreaming of the holidays.

15 Of The Best Cookie Exchange Recipes To Whip Up For Your Party (8)Here is a citrus twist to a cookie. A lemon shortbread cookie that is light and refreshing and melt in your mouth. The perfect tang and sweet all in one.

Check out this classic snickerdoodle recipe that gives you that chewy and flavorful cookie that melts in your mouth with tasty flavor.

Whip up these tropical white chocolate chip cookies for a fruit-filled cookie that is full of tropical fruit. Pineapple, coconut, macadamia nuts and more.

15 Of The Best Cookie Exchange Recipes To Whip Up For Your Party (9)

What is your favorite cookie recipe?

15 Of The Best Cookie Exchange Recipes To Whip Up For Your Party (10)

EASY MEALS, HAPPY FAMILIES

Tired of the daily dinner dilemma? Grab our FREE Meals Made Easy Planner and say hello to quick, satisfying family meals. Plus, get our BONUS Low-Stress Lunchbox Planner FREE for a limited time!

UNLOCK EASY MEAL PLANNING NOW

You Might Also Like

28 Irresistible Camping Food Ideas

15 Copycat Cheesecake Factory Recipes That Are Almost Too Good to Eat

18 Icebox Cake Recipes to Make Dessert Easier Than Ever

15 Red Lobster Copycat Recipes to Try at Home

Food for Families Yummy Recipes

15 Of The Best Cookie Exchange Recipes To Whip Up For Your Party (2024)

FAQs

How do you make a successful cookie exchange party? ›

Tips for hosting a fun cookie swap party
  1. Create your guest list. ...
  2. Make the rules. ...
  3. Decide on a theme. ...
  4. Send out the invites. ...
  5. Check RSVPs. ...
  6. Bake the cookies. ...
  7. Share the recipe. ...
  8. Prepare some snacks and drinks.
May 23, 2023

What food do you serve at a cookie exchange? ›

While cookies are the main event, you'll have a much more well-rounded celebration if you offer a few other savory items to snack on. You can't go wrong with appetizers and finger foods like cheese and charcuterie boards, crudite and dips, and fresh fruit.

How many cookies to bring to a cookie exchange? ›

A good rule to follow is for every guest to bake a half dozen cookies per each attendee. So, if 10 people attend, each guest would bring five dozen cookies to share. We've put together a chart to help you figure out just how many cookies to ask your guests to make.

Which cookie do people like the most? ›

What is America's favorite cookie flavor? While Americans enjoy an incredible variety of cookies, chocolate chip is the most popular.

What are the rules for a cookie exchange? ›

3. Cookie Exchange Rules
  1. Cookie Type: Each guest is responsible for bringing a certain kind of cookie for the swap. ...
  2. Cookie Amount: Typically, each participant should bring 7-8 dozen cookies for a successful cookie exchange. ...
  3. Recipes: Each guest should provide the recipe for the cookie in advance.
Dec 4, 2019

How to package cookies for cookie exchange? ›

Stack up several cookies right in the center of a sheet of wax or parchment paper. Fold the paper around your cookies like a gift package and tie it with a colorful ribbon. It's a festive way to wrap your cookies as gifts or to store them neatly in a container.

What is the cookie exchange tradition? ›

Cookie exchanges are a centuries-old tradition dating back to medieval times. The classic idea is of a holiday party in which guests bring a selection of homemade cookies to trade with one another.

How to host a recipe swap? ›

Cake decorating, pastry making, etc.
  1. Choose the menu for the first meeting.
  2. Assign the dishes.
  3. Each participant should bring or email their recipe with enough food for everyone to sample.
  4. Get together and enjoy each other's company and dishes.
Mar 1, 2018

Can you bring store-bought cookies to a cookie exchange? ›

The Rules of the Cookie Exchange - Cookie Exchange.com. All cookies should be homemade, baked and main ingredient must be flour. No plain chocolate chip cookies, cookie mixes, no-bakes, meringues or bars.

How many cookies for 8 people? ›

For these kinds of receptions, you may want to consider 3-6 cookies per person, especially if you're going for a buffet-style dessert table.

How much can you sell 1 cookie for? ›

Many simple cookies sell for between $2.00 and $5.00 each, but it's not uncommon to see a dozen cookies cost $55 or more depending on the time and ingredients that went into making them. Some people charge $10 or more per cookie because of their decorative, custom designs.

What is the #1 cookie in the world? ›

Oreo is the best-selling cookie in the world. It is now sold in over 100 countries. Oreo was first produced in 1912 by the National Biscuit Company, now known as Na-Bis-Co.

What are the top 10 cookies? ›

10 Most Popular Homemade Cookies
  • ONE. Chocolate Chip Cookies.
  • TWO. Peanut Butter Cookies.
  • THREE. Oatmeal Raisin Cookies.
  • FOUR. Peanut Butter Blossoms.
  • FIVE. Sugar Cookies.
  • SIX. Classic No-Bake Cookies.
  • SEVEN. Molasses Cookies.
  • EIGHT. Macaroons.
Mar 28, 2020

What is the 2nd most popular cookie? ›

Nabisco Oreo was the second ranked cookie brand of the United States with about 674.2 million U.S. dollars worth of sales in 2017.

How many cookies to give as a gift? ›

How many cookies should you gift?
Party sizeNumber of guestsNumber of cookies
Little party5 to 1015-30 cookies
Medium party10 to 1530 – 45
Big party20 – 5075 – 150

How many days before a party should I make cookies? ›

My advice.... make the cookies a day ahead. Even two days. Even more than that and freeze them.

How do you host a cookie challenge? ›

How to Host Your Own Christmas Cookie Showdown
  1. Gather the baking materials. As with any party, preparation is key. ...
  2. Establish the stakes. When cookies are the name of the game, everyone wins, but nothing amps up the competition factor like a grand prize. ...
  3. Decide on cookie themes. ...
  4. And the winner is… ...
  5. Enjoy your cookies!
Dec 22, 2023

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Pres. Carey Rath

Last Updated:

Views: 5396

Rating: 4 / 5 (61 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Pres. Carey Rath

Birthday: 1997-03-06

Address: 14955 Ledner Trail, East Rodrickfort, NE 85127-8369

Phone: +18682428114917

Job: National Technology Representative

Hobby: Sand art, Drama, Web surfing, Cycling, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Leather crafting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Pres. Carey Rath, I am a faithful, funny, vast, joyous, lively, brave, glamorous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.