Building a Strong Defense: Insurance Fraud Case (2024)

Insurance fraud is a serious problem that costs companies and consumers billions of dollars each year. It can be difficult to detect, and the consequences for those caught are serious. As such, it’s important to understand how to build a defense for someone accused of insurance fraud in order to secure the best possible outcome.

To establish how to build a defense in an insurance case, knowing what defines insurance fraud, what the investigation consists of, and which evidence is admissible are critical components. This article will discuss those and more to help you navigate the waters of strategizing a defense according to the legal expertise of a Michigan criminal defense lawyer.

How Is Insurance Fraud Legally Defined?

When someone lies or makes a false statement in order to benefit financially from insurance coverage, this is known as insurance fraud. Particular guidelines for fraud can vary per jurisdiction, but those accountable for insurance fraud may be physicians, hospitals, corporations, agents, insurance adjusters, or consumers.

Various fraud scenarios include:

• False claims are made by exaggerating the severity of a loss, damage, or injury or by submitting claims for events that did not actually take place.
• Staging accidents or purposefully causing damage to property in order to create false insurance claims.
• Giving false information or omitting material information from an insurance application in order to minimize the cost of the policy or coverage or to get coverage that would otherwise be rejected.
• Fraudulently representing elements that affect the premium computation, such as the location, use, or value of the insured property, in order to manipulate insurance premiums.
• Falsifying medical records, invoicing for services that were not provided, or requesting payment for treatments that were not necessary are all examples of medical fraud.

Hard Fraud vs. Soft Fraud

Along with various scenarios of fraud come various forms. Fraudulent activity is categorized as either hard fraud or soft fraud. The difference between the two is that hard fraud occurs when a policy member purposefully destroys property to obtain a payout. In contrast, soft fraud is when a policyholder lies when filing a claim to be quoted at a lower rate.

With over 20% of insurance claims suspected of fraudulent activity in 2021, soft fraud has been the most common but hardest to prove. The insurance industry loses about four percent of its earnings each year due to fraud, so certain instances are aggressively pursued through court.

How Will the Insurance Agency Know I Committed Fraud?

Fraud is estimated to cost consumers and businesses $308.6 billion annually, according to the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud. Investigations against it are tailored to assess fraudulent activities in different ways, so each insurance agency’s investigative process may vary.

In strategizing a defense against you for insurance fraud, the insurance agency may follow a protocol similar to the following:

Initial Report

When a victim or someone with knowledge of the alleged fraud contacts law enforcement, the investigation gets started. The information that started the investigation is included in this report.

Evidence Collection

To gather evidence, investigators interview witnesses, perform forensic analysis, go over bank records, go through digital evidence, and take any other actions required to establish the elements of the fraud and find potential offenders.

Identification of Suspects

Using the evidence gathered, detectives try to pin down possible fraud suspects. In order to do this, it may be necessary to examine financial transactions, track down funds, and link specific people to fraudulent activity.

Interviews and Statements

Investigators may question witnesses, suspects, and anybody else who may be able to provide information that is important to the case. These interviews aid in gathering more proof, elucidating specifics, and obtaining remarks that can be used as proof.

Building the Case

As the investigation goes on, the investigators gather information, record their findings, and build a solid case against the suspects. As part of this, the evidence must be arranged to show the accused’s criminal intent and to support the various components of the fraud.

Prosecutorial Review

Following the conclusion of the investigation, the case is ordinarily examined by the office of the district attorney or another appropriate body. They evaluate the quality of the evidence, the possibility of a conviction, and the overall advantages of pressing charges.

Criminal Charges

The prosecuting authorities have the right to bring charges against the fraud suspects if they think there is enough evidence to do so. This starts the formal legal process and prepares the ground for a court case.

What Triggers Insurance Fraud to be Investigated?

Numerous things can trigger an insurance fraud investigation. The most frequent triggers are when an insurance company notices an unusually high number of claims or if the insured exhibits suspicious conduct that could be a sign of fraud.

Discrepancies between the facts and the information supplied on the application, a considerable rise in the value of the covered property, or excessive claims from a single policy are a few additional red flags that could start an investigation. Insurance companies may launch a review to see if there is proof of fraud if any of these triggers take place.

What Evidence Will Be Used to Prove Insurance Fraud?

Investigators and prosecutors often use a variety of sorts of evidence to demonstrate insurance fraud. Depending on the nature of the claimed fraud and the applicable laws, the specific proof may vary, but the following common sorts of evidence can be used:

• Policy documents
• Surveillance footage
• Witness statements
• Financial record
• Expert testimonies
• Communication records
• Sting operations

When establishing a defense in an insurance fraud case, investigators and prosecutors will fight to build a solid case of admissible evidence against you. With the help of a criminal defense lawyer, we can ensure your rights are protected and will fight to uphold your interests.

What Are the Penalties for Insurance Fraud?

Due to intentional deceit and financial loss to insurance companies, insurance fraud is typically regarded as a criminal offense. Depending on the jurisdiction and the particular facts of the case, different punishments may be imposed for insurance fraud.

Insurance fraud is a crime that can result in fines, jail time, or both in many jurisdictions. In some instances, you can be prosecuted on a federal level. Additionally, anyone convicted of insurance fraud might need to make reparation payments to the harmed insurance provider.

How Will an Insurance Fraud Defense Lawyer Help My Case?

To create a solid defense in an insurance fraud case, your criminal defense lawyer can help by informing you of insurance regulations, analyzing evidence carefully, interviewing witnesses and experts, and identifying when there is a lack of evidence.

The prosecution in an insurance fraud case has to prove that you knowingly committed fraud “beyond a reasonable doubt.” However, a reputable insurance fraud defense attorney will be equipped to identify flaws in the investigation, negotiate a plea bargain, and litigate your defense in court if necessary.

Is it Easy to Beat an Insurance Fraud Case?

Every act of insurance fraud is not the same, so the chances of beating your particular case will depend on the extent to which fraudulent activity occurred.

Mounting a defense in an insurance fraud case can be difficult without a solid grasp of the relevant rules and legislation. To make sure that legal requirements are being followed and your rights are safeguarded during the investigation, it is crucial to speak with an experienced insurance fraud criminal defense attorney.