Summary
- Truman did call Oppenheimer a 'crybaby scientist' but not directly or during the depicted event.
- Events in Oppenheimer film differed slightly from historical reality, adding drama to the scene.
- Nolan clarified Truman's remark as a response to Oppenheimer expressing guilt post-atomic bombings.
In Christopher Nolan’s Oppenheimer, President Truman calls J. Robert Oppenheimer a “crybaby,” a remark that feels almost too petty to be rooted in reality. Biopics must tread a fine line when telling a story based on real events. This is especially true if they cover grave and complex topics. In such cases, films must be careful when deciding which aspects of the story receive nuance and which do not. The way Oppenheimer approaches this balance, especially during its inflammatory meeting between Oppenheimer and Gary Oldman's President Truman, makes the movie even more interesting when compared to history.
Oppenheimer tells the story of the titular theoretical physicist, who was pivotal in the development of the first nuclear weapons during World War II. While Oppenheimer's timeline alternates between the physicist's school years, his work at Los Alamos, and his later security hearings, it also includes an emotionally charged scene after atomic bombs are dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. In this scene, Oppenheimer meets with President Truman to urge restraint when developing such weapons. However, the meeting doesn't go well, and Truman calls Oppenheimer a "crybaby" before forbidding him from returning to the White House.
Technically, The President Did Call Oppenheimer A "Crybaby Scientist"
It may not have occurred at the point in time depicted in the movie.
The on-screen argument between Oppenheimer and President Truman may leave viewers wondering if Nolan fabricated this volatile exchange or if it actually happened in real life. Technically, Truman's response to Oppenheimer is accurate to history. However, events unfolded differently than in the film.
In reality, Truman did refer to Oppenheimer as a “crybaby scientist,” but this was not said directly to his face, nor was it in reference to barring him from the White House. According to Ray Monk's Robert Oppenheimer: A Life Inside the Center, President Truman privately described Oppenheimer as a “crybaby scientist” to his aides. He later told Dean Acheson, his Secretary of State, that he didn’t want to see the physicist in his office ever again.
Related
10 Biggest Parts Of Oppenheimer's Life Christopher Nolan's Movie Leaves Out
Christopher Nolan’s biopic about J. Robert Oppenheimer is a fairly accurate portrayal, but the movie leaves out certain events from his life.
Why President Truman Didn't Like Robert Oppenheimer
Truman saw Oppenheimer's guilt as a sign of weakness.
Ultimately, Oppenheimer correctly depicts how Truman took issue with Oppenheimer's suggestion. According to Monk’s biography, Truman was incensed by Oppenheimer’s remark about having blood on his hands, saying, “Blood on his hands, dammit, he hasn’t half as much blood on his hands as I have. You just don’t go around bellyaching about it.” As Oppenheimer demonstrates, Truman took Oppenheimer’s response to the bombs’ devastation as a sign of weakness, especially after the damage had already been done. It’s impossible to tell if Oppenheimer’s words elicited a sense of guilt on the part of the President, but it seems likely.
Blood on his hands, dammit, he hasn’t half as much blood on his hands as I have.
While the film does not include familial opinions, the ending of Oppenheimer reiterates how the physicist felt about his work on the atomic bomb. And Oppenheimer's family offered further clarity about Truman's response to the scientist. According to his grandson, Charles Oppenheimer, “He didn’t convince the president, and the president didn’t like him, unfortunately. My grandfather gave the right advice, and the president didn’t take it. What he said about having blood on his hands was clearly something Truman didn’t like” (via The Washington Post).
The Real Meaning Of Oppenheimer's Crybaby Scene Explained By Christopher Nolan
Nolan clarified the intent behind Truman's seemingly harsh dig at Oppenheimer.
While the scene that played out in Oppenheimer may not have occurred exactly as Nolan depicted it, he had good reason to include it in the film. He clarified his purpose in an interview with Slash Film, saying of President Truman's comment, "It's basically his way of saying, "Sorry Oppie, but you can't spend years working to build an atomic bomb and then act all sad and guilty when it's used for its intended purpose."" Even if the scene in Oppenheimer isn't 100% accurate to history, it is still a great demonstration of President Truman's feelings about J. Robert Oppenheimer after the bombs had fallen on Japan.
Source: The Washington Post, Robert Oppenheimer: A Life Inside The Center, Slash Film
Oppenheimer
4.5
R
Drama
History
Biography
Where to Watch
- stream
- rent
- buy
*Availability in US
Oppenheimer is a film by Christopher Nolan, which follows the theoretical physicist J. Robert Oppenheimer, the man behind the atomic bomb. Cillian Murphy will play the titular role, with the story based on the book American Prometheus: The Triumph and Tragedy of J. Robert Oppenheimer by Kai Bird and Martin J. Sherwin.
- Release Date
- July 21, 2023
- Director
- Christopher Nolan
- Cast
- Cillian Murphy , Emily Blunt , Matt Damon , Robert Downey Jr. , Rami Malek , Florence Pugh
- Runtime
- 150 Minutes
- Writers
- Christopher Nolan
- Budget
- $100 Million
- Studio(s)
- Syncopy Inc. , Atlas Entertainment
- Distributor(s)
- Universal Pictures
