- Report this article
Ray Williams
Ray Williams
Author / Retired Executive Coach / Helping Others Live Better Lives
Published Jan 17, 2016
+ Follow
There's an urban myth that interviewers make their hiring decisions within the first four minutes of an interview and spend the remaining time seeking information to bolster that gut judgment.
The evidence for this is extremely limited and probably originates with a 1954 doctoral thesis. Now Rachel Frieder and her colleagues have conducted a field study involving hundreds of real interviews and they say that claims about snap decisions in interviews are exaggerated.
The researchers collected their data from a careers fair at a university where 166 interviewers (73 per cent were male; average age 36 with an average 13 years interviewing experience) from a range of organisations interviewed 691 undergrad and post-grad job applicants (68.9 per cent were male; average age 23). The interviewers answered questions about their interview approach before they started interviewing, and they also answered questions after each interview, including how long it had taken them to make a hiring decision.
Although the interviewers certainly reported making some snap decisions (4.9 per cent of decisions were made within one minute; about 30 per cent within 5 minutes), the vast majority (69.9 per cent) occurred after five minutes or longer. This includes 17.7 per cent of decisions made after 15 minutes and 22.5 per cent made after the interview had ended.
Frieder and her team also looked for factors that correlated with decision making time. Among their findings – interviewers who tried to strike up rapport with small talk and friendly chat tended to make quicker decisions, as did interviewers with more experience and confidence in their abilities. Among interviewers with more training, the link between rapport building and snap judgments disappeared. These findings have obvious implications for organisations.
"The fact that interviewers with more experience and higher interviewing efficacy [i.e. more confidence] tend to make quicker decisions is particularly troubling," the researchers said, "as such individuals may have a large impact on which applicants are brought into an organisation."
Decision time also changed over the course of interviews – it grew progressively longer over an interviewers' first few interviews (presumably with the increasing challenge of juggling so much information), peaked, then shortened over later interviews, probably as the increasing mental demands encouraged a switch to gut decision making.
This finding also has important implications – as a candidate, it suggests that the way you are evaluated will vary depending on where you are in the interview schedule.
Source: Frieder, R., Van Iddekinge, C., & Raymark, P. (2015). How quickly do interviewers reach decisions? An examination of interviewers' decision-making time across applicants Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology
Like
Celebrate
Support
Love
Insightful
Funny
2
1 Comment
Jim Durling
Reliability, Maintainability, and Safety (RAMS) Senior Engineering Specialist (Consultant)
8y
- Report this comment
When I interviewed people for work you generally had an idea whether the person fits into the organization, is capable, and is likeable within a few minutes but not the first five seconds!!! Now I am out of work they see gray hair and say the interview is over!!! https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/what-i-offer-engineering-organization-jim-durling?trk=prof-post. They assume I know nothing about technology, even though I am an electronics engineer, and I worked on microelectronics about the time their parents were born ...or they say go take programming classes and learn about technology. (I had an office once not to far from Jack Kilby, PhD - Texas Instruments who won a Nobel Prize from the development of the microcircuit.) Or the twenty-two year old recruiter says they are too busy doing year end budgets to call you back...but you probably don't know what they do at Christmas time (even though I worked doing that stuff for decades)...
1Reaction
To view or add a comment, sign in
More articles by Ray Williams
-
The More Secure You Feel, the Less You Will Value Your "Stuff."
Sep 11, 2024
The More Secure You Feel, the Less You Will Value Your "Stuff."
According to research from the University of New Hampshire, people who feel more secure in receiving love and…
1
-
Practice Often Doesn’t Make Perfect
Sep 10, 2024
Practice Often Doesn’t Make Perfect
What causes the distinction between professional and amateur performance? With enough preparation, can anyone become a…
-
Living Well and Living Longer: What Matters Most?
Sep 6, 2024
Living Well and Living Longer: What Matters Most?
Have you ever wondered what makes life worth living? Researchers Frank Martela and colleagues, in their research…
2
-
How Physical Attractiveness Can Lead to Self-Deception and Economic Inequality
Sep 5, 2024
How Physical Attractiveness Can Lead to Self-Deception and Economic Inequality
Physically attractive people have many advantages in life, as I describe in detail in my article, “Does Physical…
4
2 Comments
-
Mud, Mayhem, and Misery: How Our Obsession with SUVs Is Damaging Nature
Sep 3, 2024
Mud, Mayhem, and Misery: How Our Obsession with SUVs Is Damaging Nature
You’ve probably seen this advertisem*nt or social media video before the SUV racing down a winding narrow dirt road in…
-
Why We Need Kindness in the World Now, More Than Ever
Sep 1, 2024
Why We Need Kindness in the World Now, More Than Ever
“Remember, there’s no such thing as a small act of kindness. Every act creates a ripple with no logical end.
8
5 Comments
-
Why Good Character is Essential for Great Leadership
Aug 29, 2024
Why Good Character is Essential for Great Leadership
The current political climate in the United States has brought into clear view the importance of candidates being of…
4
-
Toxic Bosses are a Persistent Global Problem
Aug 26, 2024
Toxic Bosses are a Persistent Global Problem
Despite progress being made in hiring ethical, wise and humble leaders in middle management and the C-Suite, toxic…
3
-
Why Women May Be Better Leaders for Our Chaotic Times
Aug 23, 2024
Why Women May Be Better Leaders for Our Chaotic Times
Men have dominated Western culture for centuries, with men being showcased as being superior and women being considered…
7
-
Remembrance of the Terrible Price of War
Aug 18, 2024
Remembrance of the Terrible Price of War
Let me begin by saying that I have a personal interest in the story behind this article. My family spent almost four…
6
4 Comments
See all articles
Sign in
Stay updated on your professional world
Sign in
By clicking Continue to join or sign in, you agree to LinkedIn’s User Agreement, Privacy Policy, and Cookie Policy.
New to LinkedIn? Join now
Insights from the community
- Critical Thinking How can you identify biases in job interviews?
- Global Talent Acquisition What do you do if a candidate struggles to provide specific examples in a behavioral interview?
- Human Resources What do you do if a candidate's behavioral interview answers lack depth?
- Strategy Here's how you can showcase your understanding of industry trends in an interview.
- Interviewing Here's how you can navigate age concerns during an interview.
- Interviewing How can you avoid bias when reviewing interview notes?
- Interviewing What are some strategies to ensure diverse candidates feel comfortable during interviews?
- Recruiting How do you decide who to hire after an interview?
- Interviewing How do you mix behavioral and technical questions in interviews?
- Career Development Coaching What are the best ways to prepare for interviews with multiple rounds?
Others also viewed
- Over 40? The Major Interview Mistake You Could Be Making J.T. O'Donnell 9y
- Understanding the Interviewer CS Mock 2y
- Age 40+ Job Seeker And Getting Interviews ... Are They Real Or Fake? Phil Rosenberg 2mo
- Why do employers make job candidates suffer endless rounds of interviews? Adrian Tan 2y
- Age 40+? Most Of Your Interviews Are Fake And How To Get Real Ones Phil Rosenberg 6mo
- The Interview Questions Candidates Most Desire Don Martinez MCC, ZLC 3mo
- Age 40+? Most Of Your Interviews Are Fake And How To Get Real Ones Phil Rosenberg 1y
- The Most Common (And Worst) First Impression Candidates Over 40 Make Phil Rosenberg 2y
- Why You're Losing Candidates During the Interview Stage (and How to Fix It) Kinga Wilson 1y
- Interviews - what companies look for in people? Nathan SV 7y
Explore topics
- Sales
- Marketing
- IT Services
- Business Administration
- HR Management
- Engineering
- Soft Skills
- See All