This post is locked.
Dovahmasters·8/22/2015in Versus Debates
this is one I have a very hard time deciding because on one hand Itachi has stronger genjutsu, but on the other Sasuke has stronger ninjutsu and dojutsu. Sasuke has much more chakra, but Itachi is more intelligent. Sasuke's faster than Itachi but both their sharingan can read movement. Sasuke's Susanoo sword is just as much an instant kill due to the Amaterasu flames the sword can produce, but Itachi has the Yata mirror which gives it better defense. Sasuke's Susanoo harpoon arrow is faster and stronger than Itachi's Yasaka Magatama but it may not be able to break through Yata mirror.
if I were forced to choose a victor I would have to go with Sasuke with extreme difficulty and only due to his superior chakra reserves. I don't think Itachi's genjutsu is going to come to play as Sasuke has broken through Itachi's tsukuyomi before and he can do it again if need be. I don't think Sasuke's faster movement speed would make much difference as sharingan can read movement and Sasuke isn't that much faster than Itachi. Itachi can probably block Amaterasu with his Susanoo but so can Sasuke.
(Edited by Dovahmasters)
JOA20·8/23/2015
Itachi wins, because he has the Totsuka Sword and Yata Mirror. Unless Sasuke finds a way to deal with these weapons, he can't win. Genjutsu, Itachi is better but not to the point where Sasuke can't do a thing. Ninjutsu, Sasuke has higher chakra levels and his Amaterasu surpasses Itachi's. Taijutsu, pretty much tied.
(Edited by JOA20)
QuakingStar·8/23/2015
Like I've said before, Itachi was an Edo Tensei when Sasuke "kept up" with him.. Edo Tensei's are laughable compared to their living forms which is proven already. Prime Itachi means living, full eyesight and no disease. He would be too much for EMS Sasuke period. He is also a better think and tactical fighter than Sasuke and he is smarter than Sasuke.
(Edited by QuakingStar)
Thekillman·8/23/2015
QuakingStar wrote:This has been done before, Itachi won. That thread was LONG AF.. Itachi would win.
I think it depends on the particular Susanoo Sasuke is using. Perfect susanoo wins Sasuke the match, but anything less and i think Itachi takes the prize.
(Edited by Thekillman)
Minato 87·8/23/2015
Sasuke in Gaiden (without Rinnegan) would beat Prime Itachi. Prime Itachi will beat EMS Sasuke (without Perfect Susanoo), his intelligence will lead him to victory.
(Edited by Minato 87)
Six paths mode·10/30/2020
Itachi let sasuke break out of the tsukoyomi tho
Masterillusionabc·11/16/2020
Prime Itachi is really strong and I guess Itachi will take this fight. but I have a question for everybody, Can EMS Sasuke defeat Juubito in a 1v1?
Hero1437·12/21/2020
Itachi sasuke sulli cheekithey itachi gelusthadu
Galaxy2King·5/12/2021
Sasuke wins
Inder220044·6/1/2021
Ok...i am sorry...here i personally believe prime itachi with just ms absolutely claps wartime sasuke before he got rinnegan. there are many reasons. less chakra reserves u say? did u forget he had less chakra reserves just cause of illness? imagine just how much chakra he had to use to keep illness at at bay he probably burned out his coils for years before he got to his final fight against sasuke. prime itachi is hard to imagine. also people tend forget that itachi didnt JUST have the greatest tactical mind that gives kakashi,4th hokage or shikamaru run for money.(kakashi was smart in battle field but no where near itachi, minato specialized more in book definition of academics not in battle field, he was op smart in battle field too but his main focus was academics. shikamaru on the other hand is a genius in strategies and big PP plays but not in battle front tactics, he the type who prefers to outsmart the outsmart outsmarting of his enemies in long run lol.) he also had more knowledge about the sharingan than sasuke could possibly ever have. dont forget until sasuke met hogoromo he was very limited in knowlegde of his bloodline, most hidden abilities of sharingan where not known to sasuke and who knows wtf else itachi had up his sleeve. itachi just had a much freater edge over sasuke in terms of knowledge and experience, sasuke was more or less self taught about his clan and blood line (not the eye but the blood line) while itachi was taught in uchiha clan as most likely there nxt head. itachi's genjustsu was greater than sasuke's ever, dont forget with weakening chakra overtime itachi's abilities and effectiveness of justsu's most likely also decreased. it is still a posilibity that itachi might have still gone easy against sasuke in final fight cause his goal was to die himself by sasuke's hands instead of killing sasuke first than diying himself cause of illness catching up. there is really no telling just how strong he was in his prime specially if he had decided to get ems through fugaku's eyes or he could have gone looking for danzo and get shisui uchiha's eyes back and transplant them. itachi had countless opportunities to get ems... also in his prime he could most likely use perfect susanoo too as shown in Naruto Shippūden: Ultimate Ninja Storm 4, my guess is he never actually used in naruto is because of illness, as seen in sasuke's case he is probably the fastest uchiha to go blind cause of recklessness and over use of big justsu's. itachi used his eyes much more than sasuke could have ever imagined but itachi just knew alot more about his eyes and used them wisely, also he hanged around a teammate ALL the time to minimize his use of sharingan. as for edo tensei itachi? there was no use for full body perfect susanoo with his indestructible body and also he was much weaker than his prime. probably 4 people who know the most about sharingan are Hogoromo, black zetsu, Madara and itachi(not sure about kaguya since there wasnt much information and sharingan only really came to prime much after her death.)
(Edited by Inder220044)
1
Squinty97·6/1/2021
Why do you see a thread from 2015 and think it's primetime to comment? SMH
