iStock / Getty Images Plus
Another blow to the ESG movement today — that’s“environmental, social and governance,” shorthand for efforts to get companies to consider those factors when making business decisions.
Investment firms JPMorgan Asset Management and State Street Global Advisors both pulled out of Climate Action 100 plus, and Blackrock is reducing its involvement. Altogether it means about $14 trillion leaving that effort.
So does this mark the beginning of the end of the ESG movement?
Despite these high-profile departures, “I don’t think that that ESG is dead,” said Sam Hartzmark, who teaches finance at Boston College.
“I will say I think the term ESG might be dead, even if what most people mean by ESG is still going to go on,” said Hartzmark.
Hartzmark says companies will still pay attention to the environment, social and governance issues but maybe call it something else or focus on one category more than another.
Many firms have been under pressure from Republicans to back away from ESG goals, especially on climate issues.
Sarah Hunt is president of the Joseph Rainey Center for Public Policy. And says she understands these companies’ moves.
“It just means that they are being cautious as being perceived as political — as they should be. Because that isn’t their job. Their job is to manage the money,” said Hunt.
Hunt compares to the political pressure to get companies to bail on ESG goals to the efforts from progressives that got companies to sign on in the first place.
“Trying to pressure asset managers from the right or the left with boycotts or bans or being part of coalitions seen as very political, it’s a distraction from their fiduciary duty to maximize returns,” said Hunt.
But many advocates argue ESG is a key part of companies’ fiduciary duties. Leanne Keddie teaches accounting at Carleton University. And says when big companies back away from ESG efforts, it sends a bad signal to other companies.
“Public commitments are one of the ways that we can hold some of these organizations to account. So I feel like pulling out of some of those public commitments, it’s a loss of accountability,” said Keddie.
At a time, says Keddie, when we need that accountability more than ever.
There’s a lot happening in the world. Through it all, Marketplace is here for you.
You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible.
Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.
FAQs
Companies are pulling back on mentions of environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues in their financial reporting, according to an analysis by Bloomberg. There was a 60% drop in mentions of ESG in the US and a 10% drop in Europe in the financial filings of the top 100 companies there.
What companies are pulling out of ESG? ›
As a result, some companies have toned down their stances on ESG publicly. Firms including Vanguard, J.P. Morgan, State Street, Pimco, and Invesco have left organizations such as the Net Zero Asset Managers Initiative or Climate Action 100+.
Do investors really care about ESG? ›
Investors increasingly believe companies that perform well on ESG are less risky, better positioned for the long term and better prepared for uncertainty.
What are the six key challenges for financial institutions to deal with ESG risks? ›
Key challenges and good practices
- Striking the right balance: anticipating adequately to relevant risks.
- Translating the ESG strategy into the organization's ecosystem.
- Adapting stakeholder management and spreading ESG knowledge in-house.
- Collecting, managing and using ESG data for risk modelling.
Challenges in data quality and standardisation
A primary challenge in ESG reporting is the acquisition and verification of high-quality data. Financial institutions often struggle with extracting relevant data to measure performance on ESG metrics from investments.
Which investment firms are pushing ESG? ›
We've ranked the top ESG fund managers on factors including ESG investment strategies, performance, transparency and commitment to sustainable practices.
- Federated Hermes. Federated Hermes.
- Parnassus. ...
- BlackRock. ...
- Amundi. ...
- SSGA (State Street Global Advisors) ...
- Vanguard Group. ...
- Nuveen (a subsidiary of TIAA) ...
- Charles Schwab. ...
Among the latest conservative culture wars is a crusade against environmental, social, and governance investing, a practice in which companies take into account non-financial factors like greenhouse gas emissions when making business decisions.
What are the downsides of ESG? ›
However, there are also some cons to ESG investing. First, ESG funds may carry higher-than-average expense ratios. This is because ESG investing requires more research and due diligence, which can be costly. Second, ESG investing can be subjective.
Is ESG falling out of favor? ›
Now the term is falling out of favor. S&P 500 companies citing “ESG” on earnings calls last quarter reached their lowest number since the same quarter in 2020, according to FactSet data. Dedicated ESG funds have also lost popularity with investors.
Why not to invest in ESG funds? ›
Two main critiques are offered: first, ESG investing violates the obligations of fiduciaries to solely focus on financial benefits for their customers and retirement plan participants, instead favoring social and environmental policy goals of no financial significance.
One of the main challenges is that ESG scoring methodologies tend to focus on how well companies manage their internal processes, rather than the real-world impacts of their products and services.
What are the financial risks of ESG? ›
Taking a holistic approach to ESG risks within risk management can deliver clear and tangible outcomes that move financial institutions toward a more effective, efficient and sustainable CRO function. Opportunities for growth within the Risk function. Opportunities for growth within the Risk function.
What does ESG mean for banks? ›
What is ESG in Banking? ESG in banking refers to the consideration of environmental, social, and governance factors in the banking industry. It involves evaluating the impact of investments and operations on the environment, society, and corporate governance practices.
Why is ESG controversial? ›
One of the biggest criticisms of ESG is that it perpetuates what it was partly designed to stop – greenwashing.
What is the ESG backlash? ›
Negative rhetoric surrounding ESG (Environmental, Social and Governance) has intensified into a rapidly escalating backlash in 2024. Vocal critics, who say ESG principles have no bearing on business performance, have dubbed it “woke capitalism,” warning of “ESG cartels” advancing a “secret liberal political agenda.”
Does BlackRock support ESG? ›
The new environment for cash investing
LEAF® is part of BlackRock Global Cash Management's effort to incorporate Environmental, Social and Governance (“ESG”) factors into Cash Investing.
Why are companies moving away from ESG? ›
Due to the increasing controversy, politicization and polarization of the ESG movement, many fund sponsors and institutional investors alike are moving away from having ESG-termed departments and policies, instead rebranding them with such terms as “sustainable investing” and “responsible investing.” While the ESG ...
Which industry is most affected by ESG? ›
Manufacturing is one of the industries with the greatest impact on the environment, society, and governance. Significant ESG concerns threaten its long-term viability and competitiveness.
What investment companies do not use ESG? ›
Strive Asset Management and Inspire Investing offer the largest anti-ESG funds:
- Strive U.S. Energy ETF (DRLL): $369.2 million.
- Inspire 100 ETF (BIBL): $294.5 million.
- Strive 500 ETF (STRV): $266 million.
- Inspire Corporate Bond ETF (IBD): $256 million.
- Inspire International ETF (WWJD): $193 million.
Walmart is committed to making a difference on the issues that matter to our customers and shareholders in the environmental, social and governance (ESG) areas.
