A passionate debate has ignited in Penang, Malaysia, where a recent rally has brought attention to a controversial issue: the use of corporal punishment in schools. The core of this debate lies in the question of whether teachers should be allowed to use physical discipline, and the recent charges against two teachers for caning a student have sparked a movement.
On October 26, 2025, approximately 300 individuals gathered outside SMJK Chung Hwa Confucian School to show their support for the accused teachers. The rally, organized by the renowned activist Kuan Chee Heng (Uncle Kentang), aimed to restore dignity to the teaching profession and address the growing concerns of educators.
Kuan highlighted the demoralizing effect of constant blame and unreasonable demands from some parents, stating, "It's draining the passion of teachers, leaving them disheartened."
The protesters, including teachers and members of the public, carried white balloons and banners with powerful messages. Two such messages read, "Do not treat our teachers like criminals" and "Honour those who taught you." These sentiments reflect a broader concern about the treatment of educators in society.
The Penang chapter of the National Union of the Teaching Profession (NUTP) also lent its support to the rally. Fadlee Ahmad, the honorary secretary of NUTP, emphasized the union's commitment to defending teachers who are "victimized" while performing their duties. He argued for a better understanding of teachers' roles and limits, allowing them to teach without fear or hesitation.
Fadlee further stressed the need for a comprehensive review of the caning policy. He suggested that if corporal punishment is to be reinstated, it should be accompanied by strict rules and safeguards, aligning with Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim's recent remarks.
Ravinder Singh, a retired teacher, defended the use of corporal punishment, particularly in primary schools, stating, "Discipline is essential for maintaining order and academic performance."
He shared a story about a top school in Alor Setar that experienced a decline due to a lack of discipline, emphasizing the importance of firm rules and the cane as a last resort.
The charges against the teachers stem from separate incidents in 2023. Choong Kean Beng, 59, now retired, and Lau Teik Hwa, 47, were accused of causing injury to a 15-year-old student by caning him in the school's disciplinary room. Choong pleaded not guilty before magistrate Nadratun Naim Saidi, while Lau entered the same plea before magistrate Amzar Ismail.
This case has sparked a wider conversation about the role of discipline in education. While some argue that corporal punishment is necessary to maintain order, others advocate for alternative methods. But here's where it gets controversial: should teachers have the authority to use physical discipline, or is there a better way to ensure students learn and behave?
What are your thoughts on this issue? Feel free to share your opinions and engage in a respectful discussion in the comments below!
