As the U.S. Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) cracks down on noncompliant Wild West cryptocurrency firms, a new breed of blockchain application, created from the ground up to be securities, is emerging to meet demand. This month private-equity giant KKR
That effort is the latest step into blockchain for the investment management company dubbed the Barbarians at the Gates in the 1989 book of the same name. And more compliant blockchain applications are in the works by companies around the world.
While the first generation of financial firms using the technology—described rather derisively by crypto-hardliners as Enterprise Blockchain—focused almost exclusively on so-called permissioned versions like Hyperledger Fabric and Corda, this latest movement is proving itself to be open to a wide range of technologies, including public blockchains that anyone can build on.
“Longer term, blockchain has a whole lot of applicability across the value chain of private markets,” says Dan Parant, co-head of KKR’s U.S. wealth business. “And so I do think, for asset managers and other players in the space, blockchain will make it easier to operate and administer private-equity funds, from capital calls to distribution to capital account statements that ultimately we'll move on to blockchain as well.”
Though New York-based KKR, which manages $491 billion worth of assets, is one of the few—and maybe first—U.S. private-equity firms to open one of its funds to tokenization on a public blockchain, a consortium led by iCapital, is exploring similar opportunities with 18 members, including U.S.-based BlackRock
Click here to subscribe to the Forbes CryptoAsset & Blockchain Advisor.
KKR’s secret to being early to the game goes back to 2018, when Parant says the firm hosted a competition among its employees. There, Parant and his team first identified the opportunities of fractionalizing investments using tokens on a blockchain, reducing the amount needed to invest and widening the potential universe of financiers. Without blockchain, the typical HCSG II investor was worth about $100 million. Though still not accessible to mom-and-pop types, the tokenized version of the fund was available to investors whose net wealth was as low as $5 million and for a minimum of as little as $100,000.
To pull off the feat, KKR partnered with San Francisco-based, Securitize, a broker-dealer that raised $85 million from Morgan Stanley
In September 2021, a month before Kravis and his co-CEO stepped down from the company they founded 45 years before, the firm itself formally invested in ParaFi and revealed a working group dedicated to exploring blockchain applications. By the end of the year, KKR showed it would stay the course established by its co-founder, making its first fund investment in a crypto firm, leading a $350 million investment in Anchorage Digital, a crypto custodian granted conditional approval to operate as a bank.
Showing the sheer breadth of the possible impact blockchain could have in private markets and beyond, KKR kicked off 2022 by joining a consortium that also included finance giants Apollo Global Management
But up until earlier this month, KKR’s crypto work had been limited to investing and team building. With the partial tokenization of its HCSG II Fund, that changed. Though Parant and Securitize declined to share the value of the tokenized portion of the investment, they said it is in the millions of dollars, a tiny fraction of the $4 billion fund of healthcare companies; was offered under SEC Reg D 506(c); and comprises exclusively qualified purchasers, meaning Securitize knows who the investors are, and they’re not violating securities requirements.
Since July the SEC has identified 10 crypto tokens as securities and in early September announced plans to review filings involving crypto assets. Domingo isn’t concerned about the crackdown. “It's very important that we're following the existing regulatory framework,” says Parant.
Though Securitize isn’t sharing revenue numbers, CEO and founder Carlos Domingo says it expects to double revenue this year and has enough capital to stay afloat at least two years, even without any additional sales. The firm’s 250 employees now connect 1.2 million investor accounts to 3,000 investment opportunities and can build compliant financial instruments on permissioned blockchains Quorum, Corda and Hyperledger as well as public blockchains including Ethereum
Though a recent report showed that the expense of being compliant might make some crypto projects untenable, Domingo says the cost of failures like Celsius
“The fact that the best investment opportunities are not offered to retail people, I think is fundamentally wrong,” says Domingo. “I should be able to invest the same as a Harvard endowment, right? And I think that those laws need to be changed, relaxed and improved. That said, the compliance rules are there for a reason. They're for investor protection. And I think in crypto people have realized that the lack of investor protection has actually resulted in a lot of retail people losing a lot of money, and that's wrong. So companies, especially companies that were making a lot of money, should have invested more in compliance to protect their investors because the ones that have ended up suffering are the investors.”
Other possible blockchain applications could involve entirely new ways to structure public funds, according to Miles Radcliffe-Trenner, KKR vice-president of public affairs. “We're very much for this first offering, following exactly how other private funds are offered in the market,” says Radcliffe-Trenner. “We want to make sure we get this one right. We want to make sure investors have a great experience. But there's definitely an opportunity in the future to think of other structures that may actually reach a broader audience of investors and be able to tokenize those structures as well.”
Ironically, for technology first adopted by privacy advocates and criminals for its supposed anonymity, Parant says blockchains could eventually help play a role in helping firms more easily comply with anti-money laundering and know-your-customer regulatory requirements. Domingo goes further, contending that issuing securities on a blockchain reduces the likelihood of missteps like the Dole Stock Crisis of 2013, when phantom shares were discovered and no one knew where they came from. He expects lessons learned from decentralized borrowing and lending protocols like Aave
“These are very novel, blockchain protocols that have a huge applicability to a huge market of trillions of dollars, which is the world of securities,” says Domingo.
