When it comes to commercial leasing, the devil is often in the details. Amid the vast web of terms and conditions, the sublease clause is a provision that many tenants might overlook. Yet, in the dynamic world of business, the flexibility offered by subleasing can be crucial. We’ve compiled a guide for commercial tenants on the importance of reviewing sublease clauses.
Understanding sublease clauses
The essence of a commercial lease is the agreement between a landlord and tenant, where the tenant pays for the use of space for a specified duration. Within this broader framework, the sublease clause plays a significant role, especially when a tenant wishes to adapt to changing circ*mstances.
The basic framework: A sublease clause permits the tenant, with certain stipulations, to rent out either a portion or the entirety of their leased space to a third party, referred to as a subtenant. This means the original lease agreement between the landlord and primary tenant remains intact, but an additional contract (the sublease) comes into existence between the primary tenant and the subtenant.
Types of Sublease Arrangements: Not all subleases are the same. They can range from:
Benefits and limitations: While the primary tenant can benefit financially by receiving rent from the subtenant, there might be limitations on how much space can be sublet and for how long. Moreover, landlords typically include clauses that require their explicit consent before any sublease can be executed.
Overarching responsibility: It's crucial to understand that the primary tenant, despite entering into a sublease agreement, is still responsible for the lease's overarching obligations. If a subtenant defaults or violates terms, it often falls upon the primary tenant to rectify the situation.
Take-back rights: Some sublease clauses include a take-back rights for landlords. This means that if a tenant expresses a desire to sublease, the landlord has the first right of refusal contingent on taking back the space instead of allowing the sublease. It gives landlords the flexibility to re-lease the space at potentially higher market rates or to a more desirable tenant.
John Reed, Director of LPC, notes, "Understanding the intricacies of sublease clauses is crucial. They not only dictate the tenant's rights but also outline the potential risks and benefits of entering into a sublease. A well-negotiated sublease clause can serve as a strategic tool for businesses to remain agile in fluctuating market conditions."
Why is Reviewing Sublease Provisions Essential?
Business flexibility: Business needs evolve. You might require less space due to technological advancements, a strategic shift towards remote work, or any number of reasons. Subleasing can be a viable solution to manage excess space.
Financial considerations: If unforeseen circ*mstances arise - perhaps economic downturns, a pandemic, or significant business changes - subleasing can help mitigate costs by bringing in rental income from subtenants.
Contractual restrictions: Not all sublease clauses are created equal. Some might come with stringent restrictions, fees, or even prohibitions against subleasing. It's vital to know the specifics.
Key Elements to Consider
Landlord consent: Many sublease clauses require you to obtain the landlord's permission before subleasing. Ensure you're aware of this stipulation and any associated processes or fees.
Profit sharing: Some clauses may dictate that any profits earned from subleasing beyond the original rent must be shared with the landlord. This can significantly impact the financial benefits of subleasing.
Responsibility: In most subleasing scenarios, the primary tenant remains responsible for the leased space. This includes ensuring that subtenants adhere to lease terms and covering any rent defaults by the subtenant.
Future-proofing your lease
Negotiation: When entering a new lease agreement or renewing an existing one, negotiate the terms of the sublease clause to align with your potential business needs. This may include pushing for more flexibility or reducing associated fees.
Legal or professional counsel: Given the complexities and potential pitfalls associated with sublease clauses, engaging professionals during negotiations is essential. They can guide you in crafting a clause that protects your interests.
Plan ahead: Even if you don't foresee an immediate need to sublease, business conditions can change rapidly. It's beneficial to plan ahead and understand your rights and restrictions concerning subleasing.
Subleasing can be an advantageous option for commercial tenants, providing both flexibility and financial relief. However, to harness its benefits effectively, a thorough understanding and strategic negotiation of the sublease clause are imperative.
Recommended by LinkedIn
John emphasises, "In the realm of commercial leasing, forethought and comprehension are invaluable. Tenants must approach sublease clauses with the same diligence as any other major lease provision. This proactive mindset can make all the difference in aligning lease terms with business objectives."
Does the PWC tax scandal have some lessons for commercial leasing in Australia?
At the heart of the scandal was a PWC consultant who shared confidential government information with colleagues in PwC's tax advisory arm, so that they could gain contracts helping multinational corporations to avoid taxation.
Kate Ainsworth commented, “What PWC did was put profits before purpose. If they got away with it, the Australian economy would have been $180 million worse off, because these big foreign companies wouldn't have been paying as much tax” (ABC News , 5 June 2023). Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC)
The question is whether there are any learnings to be gained by reflecting on the conflicts of interest that underpinned the sharing of confidential information within PWC, and considering if conflicts of interest are embedded in the regime that regulates the procurement and provision of tenant advisory services to Government.
If there are, then the further consideration is what is the impact on:
By ‘norms’ we refer to long-standing lease provisions that have not changed much in recent decades, notwithstanding the need for more flexible and more productive tenancy arrangements. The essential impact of these outdated norms is that landlords effect a substantial transfer of the risks of ownership to the tenant, whilst retaining the benefits of ownership, without due recognition of the contribution of the Government’s covenant to the growth in the value of the leased asset. The pandemic evidenced the extent of the risk transfer from landlord to tenant, with almost every commercial tenant in Australia having to meet their lease obligations notwithstanding a significant interruption to their utilisation of the leased asset due to lockdowns. The ‘after the fact’ intervention of federal and state governments did not achieve the intended support for tenants at a time when tenants desperately needed assistance.
What then can we learn?
Three conclusions stand out:
In relation to Government’s requirement for property services, the Government consolidated the procurement of tenant advisory, property management , and facilities management services across the whole of Government - this resulted in small business providers of commercial tenancy and leasing advice being excluded from working with the Australian Government, regardless of independence, capability, and capacity.
The procurement outcome was to consolidate services with multinational firms, organisations with conflicts of interest at the core of their business models. At a macro level, the Government’s procurement approach has reinforced commercial leasing norms that advantage landlords and disadvantage commercial tenants, including SMEs.
We are yet to see if the 1 July 2022 changes made to Commonwealth Procurement Rules have had the impact of increasing the participation of small business in the Commonwealth procurement activities, and more particularly whether this direction will impact the procurement arrangements for commercial property services.
As small businesses are the engine room of our economy, it would benefit the country if conflict-free SMEs (such as LPC) were given every opportunity by Government to apply their expertise to serve tenants and improve their leasing arrangements.
Given the scale of the Australian Government's leasing activities and the impact on leasing norms across all sectors, we submit that tenant enterprise (and productivity) would be enhanced by the Government's adoption of a procurement model whereby lease negotiation and related services were procured from pre-qualified Australian service providers that passed conflict-free and competence tests.
Our popular Commercial Leasing Course commences 1 November 2023
Are you grappling with the complexities of commercial leasing, particularly in today's challenging economic landscape marked by rising inflation and often onerous lease obligations? Our popular course starts again in November.
Who Should Attend?
This course is designed for professionals and business leaders who are directly or indirectly involved in the leasing process. Whether you're a new tenant navigating your first lease, an established business looking to renegotiate terms, or a manager keen to understand the nuances of your organisation's rental agreements, this course offers invaluable insights for all.
Key Takeaways:
Business-aligned Leasing Strategies: Gain the skills and knowledge to renegotiate and restructure lease agreements that align more closely with your business objectives. In today's environment of soaring occupancy costs due to rampant inflation, a strategic approach to leasing is more vital than ever.
Spot the red flags: The course explores lease terms, highlighting those that can be advantageous or detrimental to commercial tenants. You'll be equipped to identify and avoid potential pitfalls, ensuring that you're not caught off guard by any hidden clauses or unfavourable terms.
Future-proofing: One of the primary goals of the course is to empower attendees to negotiate leases that not only serve their current needs but also anticipate future challenges. By understanding and negotiating tenant-friendly terms, you can safeguard and future-proof your organisation against unforeseen adversities.
Details - Module 1:
Registration Fee: $100 incl GST
Date: 1 November 2023
Time: 11:00 – 12:00 AEST
REGISTER HERE
SYDNEY BRISBANE ADELAIDE
PERTH MELBOURNE AUCKLAND
