Picture this: You're diligently logging every bite and step in your favorite fitness app, hoping for that healthier you, but instead, you're hit with waves of shame and frustration that leave you demotivated and ready to quit. That's the startling downside uncovered in a groundbreaking study from researchers at UCL and Loughborough University. And this is the part most people miss – while these apps are meant to boost our well-being, they might actually be sabotaging it for some users. Buckle up as we dive into the findings that could change how we view our digital health companions.
This eye-opening research, published in the British Journal of Health Psychology, sifted through a massive 58,881 posts on Twitter (that's before it rebranded to X) about five well-known fitness and calorie-tracking apps. The team harnessed advanced AI tools to pinpoint 13,799 posts buzzing with negative vibes, then sorted them into key themes. What they discovered wasn't just a minor hiccup – it was a pattern of emotional turmoil that could seriously harm users' mental and physical health. For beginners diving into health apps, think of it like this: These tools are designed to guide you toward better habits, but if they're making you feel bad about yourself, it's like having a coach who constantly criticizes instead of encourages.
Users shared stories of deep shame when entering 'unhealthy' foods into their logs, annoyance at relentless notifications reminding them to cut back on sugar or track calories, and crushing disappointment when their progress lagged behind the app's automated goals. In some heartbreaking cases, this led to total demotivation, with people abandoning their health journeys entirely – the exact opposite of the motivation these apps promise to deliver. To put this in perspective, imagine training for a marathon but feeling guilty every time you enjoy a treat; it zaps the joy out of the process and turns self-improvement into self-punishment.
But here's where it gets controversial: The researchers are urging a radical shift away from the 'rigid' focus on calorie counting and exercise metrics toward a more balanced, holistic approach that emphasizes overall well-being. Senior author Dr. Paulina Bondaronek from UCL's Institute of Health Informatics explained, 'Very few studies have explored the potential downsides of these apps. Social media offers a treasure trove of real-world data, and with AI, we analyzed it swiftly and efficiently. What we saw in these posts was a lot of self-blame and shame, with folks feeling like they weren't measuring up. These emotional tolls could ultimately erode motivation and health.' She advocates for apps that prioritize intrinsic motivation – that's the genuine pleasure or satisfaction from activities, rather than just hitting numbers. Plus, many apps keep things solitary, overlooking how social connections can amplify our health and happiness. 'Self-monitoring and action planning are effective for behavior change,' Dr. Bondaronek added, 'but we're overdoing it. We need to be gentler with ourselves. Blaming and shaming might seem like a push to improve, but it often backfires, leading to worse outcomes.'
Importantly, the study only examined negative posts, so it can't paint the full picture of these apps' impacts on well-being. They might offer real benefits for many, like structured tracking that helps with weight loss or fitness gains, but this research highlights a dark side that demands attention. The researchers categorized the negative sentiments into themes, drawing from AI-generated suggestions, including the headaches of complex calorie tracking, technical glitches causing data loss, and the psychological weight of daily logging.
Take calorie tracking complexity, for example – the apps often lack the customization needed for accuracy. One user couldn't even log breastfeeding, a calorie-burning activity that deserves recognition. And get this: Some apps spat out shocking recommendations, like advising a daily intake of negative 700 calories to meet goals, which could be dangerously unsustainable. As one user warned about MyFitnessPal, 'Letting the app dictate your calories might lead to an unachievable deficit that's unhealthy and could even risk starvation.' These goals aren't always grounded in solid health guidelines, such as those from the NHS for safe daily intakes; instead, they're twisted by personal weight targets, potentially pushing unsafe extremes. For newcomers, this is a wake-up call: Always cross-check app advice with trusted sources like a doctor or official health bodies to avoid harm.
Then there's the emotional toll of logging daily activities. Users felt bombarded by pestering notifications and struggled with the inflexibility of goals, often losing steam and motivation. The study quoted examples like people avoiding logging favorite treats or ditching the app altogether after missing streaks. This echoes broader research showing that measuring activities, like a run, can sometimes diminish the fun of them – think of a Strava user nailing a personal best half-marathon but fixating on the app not recording it. Another case highlighted a user forcing themselves to the gym out of guilt over low calorie counts, driven by the app's feedback rather than true enjoyment, leading to miserable experiences.
Co-author Dr. Lucy Porter from UCL's Division of Psychology & Language Sciences emphasized, 'When we release behavior change tools into the world, we must evaluate their unintended effects. Social media insights reveal that fitness apps can demoralize users to the point of giving up – the polar opposite of their purpose! Past studies show that shame and misery don't foster lasting healthy changes. Now, we need to explore how widespread these morale hits are and how to tweak apps to better support users.' She added a bit of hope: By adapting designs to focus on positivity and social elements, apps could transform from potential downers to true allies.
Co-author Trisevgeni Papakonstantinou, also from UCL Psychology & Language Sciences, praised the use of AI for uncovering insights: 'Unsupervised machine learning allows us to mine real-world social media data that’s otherwise out of reach. This turns everyday chatter into scalable, cost-free insights for public good.'
For more details, check out the full paper: 'Living well? The unintended consequences of highly popular commercial fitness apps through social listening using Machine-Assisted Topic Analysis: Evidence from X' in the British Journal of Health Psychology (2025), DOI: 10.1111/bjhp.70026.
Citation: Emotional strain of fitness and calorie counting apps revealed (2025, October 22) retrieved 22 October 2025 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2025-10-emotional-strain-calorie-apps-revealed.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
So, what’s your take? Do you think fitness apps should ditch the strict calorie focus and embrace a kinder, more social vibe? Or have these tools been a game-changer for you despite the downsides? Is there a controversial angle here – like blaming users for over-relying on apps when personal intuition might suffice? Share your opinions in the comments; I'd love to hear diverse viewpoints and spark a conversation!
