The Hand That Rocks The Cradle (2025) Review: A Disappointing Remake
The 2025 version of 'The Hand That Rocks The Cradle' is a disappointing take on a classic 1990s thriller. While the original film, starring Rebecca De Mornay as the iconic Peyton Flanders, remains unforgettable, this remake falls short of its potential. The new nanny, Polly, played by Maika Monroe, is a chilling character, but the film fails to capture the essence of the original's dark humor and suspense. Monroe's performance is commanding, but the overall execution feels forgettable.
The story begins with Polly seeking legal advice from lawyer Caitlin Morales, played by Mary Elizabeth Winstead. Initially, Polly seems like a godsend, but Caitlin soon suspects a more sinister agenda. The film explores themes of class divide and personal envy, as Caitlin, with a history of dating women, spies on Polly's dominant behavior with her female partner. However, the film's exploration of these ideas is limited, and the climax feels rushed and predictable.
The remake attempts to update the classic with a sleeker, more clinical tone, but it fails to capture the original's trashy charm and suspenseful atmosphere. The class divide between the characters, with Caitlin's obsession with minimizing microplastics and Polly's foster home background, is a missed opportunity for deeper exploration. The film's climax, instead of challenging the audience, feels like a rushed and bloody conclusion.
Despite Monroe's strong performance, the film is ultimately frustrating and forgettable. It lacks the thrilling elements and dark humor that made the original so memorable. The remake's attempt to update the classic falls short, leaving viewers with a sense of disappointment. The film's premise, while intriguing, fails to deliver a satisfying and impactful experience.
