What Is Rescission?
Rescission is when a contract is rendered null, void, and no longer legally binding. The courts can free non-liable parties from their agreed obligations and, when possible, will effectively seek to restore them to the position they were in before the contract was signed.
Key Takeaways
- Rescission is the voiding of a contract by a court that does not recognize it as legally binding.
- Courts can free non-liable parties from their obligations in a contract.
- Rescission can occur when there is a material error in the contract, evidence of fraud, a lack of legal or mental capacity, or other applicable circ*mstances.
- Many states offer rescission on various business-to-consumer (B2C) contracts.
How Rescission Works
Rescission involves canceling a contract and treating it as though it never existed by ensuring that all its effects are eliminated. To return all parties to their original state, things that were exchanged, such as money, must be returned.
Rescinding a contract may be an option if there is proof that there was a material error in the contract. Evidence of fraud, mutual errors, lack of legal or mental capacity, duress and undue influence, or one party not fulfilling its obligation can also lead contracts to be voided.
Laws addressing rescission vary from state to state. However, for certain contracts, such as those exchanged between lendersand consumers, rescission may occasionally be federally mandated.
A contract may be deemed void should the terms require one or both parties to participate in an illegal act, or if a party becomes incapable of meeting the terms.
Types of Recission
There's three main types of recission, each of which are discussed in depth below.
Recission by Mutual Consent
Rescission by mutual consent occurs when all parties to a contract agree to terminate the contract voluntarily. This type of rescission is based on the principle that contracts can be undone by the same parties who initially entered into them. As long as all parties agree, the argument is a contract should be able to change.
With mutual consent, all parties must freely and willingly agree to terminate the contract. The agreement to rescind must be clear and unambiguous. Upon rescission, the parties seek to restore themselves to their positions prior to entering into the contract.
Recission for Breach
Rescission for breach occurs when one party fails to fulfill their obligations under the contract. This gives the other party the right to rescind the contract due to the breach. This type of rescission is typically available when the breach is substantial or fundamental, meaning it goes to the root of the contract and the innocent party didn't quite get what they needed out of the agreement.
In most cases, the breaching party's failure must be material or fundamental to the contract. For this process, the innocent party must notify the breaching party of their intention to rescind due to the breach. Rescission for breach aims to restore the innocent party to their pre-contractual position by undoing the contract, in so that the innocent party isn't able to be made whole.
Recission by Court Order
Last, rescission by court order is a type of rescission granted by a court. This usually happens if there's a a legal defect in the contract. For example, imagine a contract that was entered into where undue pressure was applied to one of the parties. This type of rescission is typically sought when the parties cannot agree on rescission or when legal intervention is necessary to rectify an unfair or defective contract.
The court must find a valid legal basis for rescinding the contract, such as misrepresentation, mistake, duress, undue influence, incapacity, or illegality. Rescission by court order is subject to judicial discretion and equitable principles. The court may order rescission alongside other remedies, such as restitution or damages (i.e. some sort of penalty).
Example of Rescission
Rescission is a common practice in the insurance industry. Insurers that provide life, fire, auto, and health coverage have a right to rescind policies without court approval, if, for example, they can prove that an application was submitted with false information. Consumers who want to fight this can then take the decision to a court.
The right ofrescissionalso applies to mortgage refinancing or home equity loans(but not to the first mortgage of a new home). If a borrower wants to cancel the loan, they must do so at the latest at midnight of the third day following the completion of the refinancing, including having received a mandatory Truth in Lending (TIL) disclosure from the lender and two copies of a notice advising them of their right to rescind. If the borrower rescinds, they must do so in writing before this deadline.
A right to rescission is typically provided on a no-questions-asked basis, as long as it takes place within the appropriate period of time.
Recission of Consumer Contracts vs. Business Contracts
Consumer Contracts
Many states have made rescission a component of various business-to-consumer (B2C) contracts to protect consumer rights. States may offer periods from 24 hours to three days, 10 days, or an indefinite period of time for rescission.The State of California, for example, offers rescission rights to consumers on over 30 different types of contracts, including those covering automobile sales, funeral contracts, and home solicitation sales.
Well-known examples of rescission availability across multiple states includetimesharesales. Transactions for a property that has several owners offer extra protection because decisions to sign up are typically made under lots of pressure.
Other contracts can be harder to break. Under the Truth in Lending Act (TILA), banks are required to give customers applying to refinance an existing loan with a new lender a three-day period to change their minds. The clock starts ticking once the contract is signed and the Truth in Lending disclosure and two copies of a notice explaining rights to rescind are received.
In contrast, those buying a new home with a mortgage have no right to cancel the loan once all the relevant documents are signed.
Business Contracts
Rescission of business contracts is much rarer. Companies tend to mediate disputes or look for compensation orremunerationthrough the court system because most of their contracts do not include clauses stating they can be rescinded.
That said, businesses may have an option to rescind a contract in certain situations, including if:
- It was formed by a party who lacked the mental capacity to do so.
- Duresscan be proven through violence or threat of violence.
- The party who formed it engaged in fraudulent claims and the misrepresentation of facts.
- Both parties made contractual mistakes.
- One party does not fulfill its obligation, also known as abreach of contract.
Recission vs. Termination
Rescission refers to the cancellation or undoing of a contract as if it never existed. In contrast, termination of a contract involves ending the contractual relationship based on the terms and conditions specified within the contract itself or under applicable law. Termination can occur for various reasons similar to recission including breach of contract, completion of contractual obligations, or by agreement between the parties.
Unlike rescission, termination does not erase the existence of the contract retroactively. Instead, it brings the contract to an end from the point of termination forward. This means obligations and liabilities up to that point typically remaining enforceable. For example, if a contract is terminated halfway, the half that was done will likely need to be paid for. If the same contract was rescinded, all else being equal, it would be 100% voided.
It's important to note that, as mentioned above, rescission is often sought to address fundamental defects in the contract's validity. Termination is a more general means of ending contractual obligations for many different reasons. Contracts that do not meet the letter of the law are likely not terminated, as the entirety of the contract would be seen as inappropriate and no prior work completed to date should be recognized as valid.
Statute of Limitations and Recission
The statute of limitations on rescission establishes the legal timeframe within which a party must exercise their right to rescind a contract. There may be a timeframe in which the grounds such as misrepresentation, mistake, or fraud must be demonstrated.
This timeframe varies by jurisdiction and typically begins from the date the claimant discovered or reasonably should have discovered the facts giving rise to the right to rescind. This approach acknowledges that parties may not immediately recognize issues with the contract at the time of formation. However, the statute of limitation also somewhat protects the other party as well, as someone may not be able to rescind a contract after it has been fully completed for quite some time.
Very generally speaking, the length of the statute of limitations can vary significantly, potentially extending to multiple years depending on the situation. Failing to bring a rescission claim within the prescribed limitation period may result in the loss of the right to rescind the contract.
What Are the Steps to Recission?
Different types of contracts will differ in the process and timeline to rescind, and some contracts may not have any provision for rescission at all. In many cases, to have a contract rescinded, a court must determine that there is a legally valid reason to void the contract. Since a contract is a binding agreement, it cannot simply be rescinded because parties have had a change of heart.
How Do You Rescind a Timeshare Contract?
Depending on the language in your contract, there are usually three routes to go to get rid of your timeshare. The first is to try to sell your timeshare to somebody else, although if you bought your timeshare new this is almost guaranteed to be a financial loss. The second is to try and negotiate with the timeshare company to break the contract. but this may come with costs and fees. Finally, if your contract has a "cooling-off" or rescission period and you are still in it, you can often return your contract without penalty. You may need to hire a lawyer specialized in timeshares to go over your contract terms. If all else fails, you can try to gift your timeshare to a friend or family member who is willing to pick up the ongoing maintenance costs.
How Long Does It Take to Rescind a Contract?
Certain contractual agreements have rescission periods written into them, sometimes by law. This gives consumers a certain amount of time, often a period of days or weeks, to change their mind without penalty (for instance, with new insurance policies or home equity loans). If one goes to court to try to cancel a contract, the legal process can take several months or longer depending on the circ*mstances and jurisdiction.
When Can You Not Rescind a Contract?
In the majority of cases, a contract is binding and cannot simply be rescinded. Courts will only nullify a contract if there is a clear and valid reason to do so. Contracts with built-in rescission periods are also unable to be canceled once that initial period has passed.
What Are Rescission Damages?
A judge may rule that a contract was unfair or misrepresented certain facts but choose not to nullify it. Instead, the judge may award monetary damages that must be paid by the offending party to the injured party.
The Bottom Line
Rescission is a legal remedy that allows parties to a contract to undo or terminate the contract, typically due to a material mistake, fraud, misrepresentation, or other valid legal grounds. It aims to restore the parties to their pre-contractual positions and nullify the contract as if it never existed.
