- Report this article
Hector Cardenas
Hector Cardenas
“Technology is Best when it Brings People Together.”
Published Mar 20, 2023
+ Follow
IPsec provides more comprehensive security for IP tunneling, while GRE tunnels work well when network teams need to tunnel with multiple protocols or multicast.
Generic Routing Encapsulation, or GRE, and IPsec both encase packets, but the two protocols have different requirements when it comes to security, data privacy, and encryption.
Let's explore each protocol and discuss the best use cases for each method of tunneling.
Generic Routing Encapsulation (GRE)
GRE, defined by RFC (Request for Comments) 2784 and updated by RFC 2890, creates an unencrypted tunnel that encapsulates an arbitrary protocol over another arbitrary network layer protocol. It can encapsulate any Layer 3 protocol that uses avalid Ethertype, enabling it to transport a variety of protocols, including IP multicast packets. GRE is best used over a trusted network path because the packets aren't encrypted, but it can be combined with an IPsec tunnel if encryption is required.
GRE headers are added to the packet that is being forwarded. The outer and inner headers are frequently IP headers but may be other Layer 3 protocols.
A GRE header can be between 4 bytes and 16 bytes long, depending on which options are enabled, with a default of 4 bytes. When used over IP, the minimum additional overhead is 24 bytes -- 20 bytes of IP outer header and 4 bytes of GRE header.
IP in IP, a similar protocol, only tunnels IP packets over IP networks and adds 20 bytes of encapsulating IP header.
Recommended by LinkedIn
IPsec
IPsec, summarized in RFC 6071, is a suite of protocols that creates an encrypted tunnel over an IP network. Its encryption and authentication mechanisms prevent eavesdropping and data modification, which explains the termvirtual private network(VPN). IPsec tunnels are frequently used to provide a secure data path between an organization's branches or mobile users and the home office or data center.VPN Tunnel Terminationscan be network gateways at branches or home devices.
The IPsec encapsulation header size depends on the mode; it's typically 50 bytes to 57 bytes, depending on the padding that is needed to create packets that are a multiple of 8 bytes.
Common characteristics between GRE and IPsec
GRE and IPsec protocols share some similar characteristics, including the following:
When to use GRE vs. IPsec
IT teams should use IPsec when they require secure IP tunneling. They should use GRE when they require tunneling without privacy and when they need to tunnel multiple protocols or multicast. Teams can combine GRE on top of IPsec when they need GRE's multiprotocol functionality combined with IPsec's data protection. Finally, keep in mind MTU issues when using tunnels.
Like
Celebrate
Support
Love
Insightful
Funny
To view or add a comment, sign in
More articles by Hector Cardenas
-
Fortigate 201F vs Fortigate 401F
Sep 14, 2024
Fortigate 201F vs Fortigate 401F
The FortiGate 201F and FortiGate 401F are both firewalls with different features and capabilities: Supported users: The…
-
Palo Alto Closes IBM QRadar SaaS Buy, Extends Security Partnership.
Sep 7, 2024
Palo Alto Closes IBM QRadar SaaS Buy, Extends Security Partnership.
Palo Alto and IBM plan to strengthen joint AI security offerings. Palo Alto Networks has closed the deal to acquire…
-
Cisco Snaps up AI Security Player Robust Intelligence.
Aug 31, 2024
Cisco Snaps up AI Security Player Robust Intelligence.
Plans call for integrating Robust Intelligence's AI security platform with Cisco Security Cloud to streamline threat…
-
F5 Teams With Intel to Boost AI Delivery and Security.
Aug 31, 2024
F5 Teams With Intel to Boost AI Delivery and Security.
F5 and Intel are working together to combine security and traffic-management capabilities from F5’s NGINX Plus suite…
-
Juniper Offers AI Pricing Incentives and Education Programs.
Aug 24, 2024
Juniper Offers AI Pricing Incentives and Education Programs.
New AI resources from Juniper are designed to streamline enterprise adoption of its AI-Native Networking Platform and…
1
-
What is a Network Router? How AI Networking Driving its Evolution.
Aug 24, 2024
What is a Network Router? How AI Networking Driving its Evolution.
Network technology has evolved, especially since the arrival of artificial intelligence (AI), and the role and the…
1
1 Comment
-
Cisco to cut 7% of workforce, restructure product groups
Aug 24, 2024
Cisco to cut 7% of workforce, restructure product groups
Cisco is cutting 6,000 jobs in its second round of layoffs this year and combining its networking, security and…
1
-
AWS Offers a Glimpse of its AI Networking Infrastructure.
Aug 12, 2024
AWS Offers a Glimpse of its AI Networking Infrastructure.
To speed up its ability to innovate, AWS builds its own network operating systems and network devices, including NICs…
2
-
Network Protection: How to Secure a Network in 13 Steps.
Aug 12, 2024
Network Protection: How to Secure a Network in 13 Steps.
Truly securing your network infrastructure is one of the most critical choices your business can make to protect itself…
-
Tagged vs Untagged VLAN: When You Should Use Each?
Aug 12, 2024
Tagged vs Untagged VLAN: When You Should Use Each?
Virtual local area networks (VLANs) are one of the most important networking innovations of the last 30 years, enabling…
1
See all articles
Sign in
Stay updated on your professional world
Sign in
By clicking Continue to join or sign in, you agree to LinkedIn’s User Agreement, Privacy Policy, and Cookie Policy.
New to LinkedIn? Join now
Insights from the community
- Network Security What are the key considerations for designing an IPsec solution?
- IPSec How do you deal with dynamic IP addresses and port changes in IPSec NAT traversal?
- Network Security What are the best practices for configuring IPsec on a Juniper SRX gateway?
- Network Security What are the best ways to improve IPsec performance?
- Network Security How does IPsec support secure 5G networks?
- Network Security How can you optimize IPsec for mobile devices?
- IPSec How do you evaluate and select IPsec encryption algorithms for cloud-based or hybrid VPN solutions?
- Network Security How can you quickly resolve IPsec issues?
- Computer Networking How can you scale your IPsec VPN to meet your needs?
- Quality of Service (QoS) How do you configure and monitor diffserv over ipsec vpn on different devices and platforms?
Others also viewed
- PROTOCOL ? Himayun Nazir 2y
- Ready for Secure Transport? Gert Grammel 4y
- Cisco Site-to-Site VPN Technologies Comparison Mate Gulic 5y
- Virtual Private Network Ahmed Shawky 7mo
- A Virtual Private Network Can Help Keep Your Company’s Data Safe Robert Mitchell 7y
- Security concepts Ash Uprety 2y
- What is the difference between IPsec and SSL? Nawwar Mohammad 3mo
- How To's: Configure IPsec Site-to-Site Tunnels between Cisco Firewall Silésio Carvalho 4y
- WireGuard's Anatomy: A Deep Dive into How It Works Mirajul Islam 10mo
- VPN's - It's Protocols Abhinav Pamarthi 2y
Explore topics
- Sales
- Marketing
- IT Services
- Business Administration
- HR Management
- Engineering
- Soft Skills
- See All