9-1-1’s Connie Britton replacement, Jennifer Love Hewitt, took center stage after the show's first season,in what initially seemed like a strange casting decision. However, despite the jarring change-up, there was actually a very good reason behind9-1-1's Jennifer Love Hewitt casting. In fact, not only was the replacement necessary, but it may even have worked to the show's advantage.
The Los Angeles-based police procedural was created by Ryan Murphy, Brad Falchuk, and Tim Minear of the wildly popular FX series American Horror Story. 9-1-1 first aired on 20th Television in January 2018. The show has received high ratings from audiences for its intense, fast-paced drama; and a spinoff series titled 9-1-1: Lone Star began in January of 2020. Connie Britton stars in 9-1-1 season 1 as Abby, a 9-1-1 operator who yearns for closure on the cases to which she bears witness. Abby’s relationshipwith Buck is central to the season. The pair’s romantic connection helps change the firefighter’s womanizing ways and allows Abby to come back out of her shell after months spent caring for her ailing mother. However, at the end of 9-1-1 season 1, Abby’s mother dies, and the bereaved daughter departs for Dublin on a journey of self-discovery - indefinitely.
Related: Every Ryan Murphy Movie & TV Show Coming In 2020
Thanks to the character's narrative departure, it made total sense for Jennifer Love Hewitt to come in as 9-1-1's Connie Britton replacement. Love Hewitt,who also appeared on the long-running CBS crime drama Criminal Minds, is introduced at the start of 9-1-1 season 2. Hewitt plays Buck’s sister, Maddie, who mysteriously appears in his apartment after years of estrangement. Maddie’s decision to become a 9-1-1 operator signals an attempt to compensate for Britton’s departure from the show, but she brings much more than just a job title to fill the void.
Beyond the narrative element, there was also a logistical reason for the replacement behind 9-1-1's Jennifer Love Hewitt casting – namely, thatBritton’s contract only lasted for one season, and she was never expected to stick with the series. The creators of 9-1-1 maintain that there is no replacing the actress, but admit that there was a gap left in the wake of Connie Britton’s exit from 9-1-1. “You need certain elements on the show,” explained Tim Minear “and we absolutely needed a face in the 9-1-1 call center” (via The Wrap). 9-1-1’s Jennifer Love Hewitt casting fixed that issue, and Minear attests that she was the “perfect choice” for the part.
There are, of course, some key differences between Abby and Maddie’s roles on 9-1-1. While Abby was a seasoned professional, viewers get to watch Maddie struggle through training as a 9-1-1 operator. This added storyline contributes to a more well-rounded portrayal of the trials of working in law enforcement. Hewitt’s entrance also enhances Buck’s storyline, and the new character adds her own dramas to the mix. Maddie’s role in 9-1-1 gives Buck a new female companion, this time a family member instead of a lover, presenting numerous opportunities for character development. The pursuit of Maddie’s abusive husband adds danger and suspense to the already action-packed plot. Overall, 9-1-1’s Connie Britton replacement does not just fill space but builds many new elements into the show.
