Why Say No Comment at a Police Interview - Legal Insights (2024)

Why Say No Comment at a Police Interview? When facing a police interview, the phrase “no comment” is often advised by legal professionals. This strategy, while seemingly straightforward, carries significant implications that can impact the course of legal proceedings. Here’s why saying no comment can be a crucial tactic and what you should know about its use.

The cornerstone of saying “no comment” lies in the right to silence, a fundamental principle in UK law. This right protects individuals from self-incrimination during police questioning. Exercising this right by saying “no comment” can prevent you from inadvertently providing evidence that could be used against you​​​​.

Benefits of Saying No Comment

1. Avoid Self-Incrimination: The primary benefit is avoiding self-incrimination. By not answering questions, you reduce the risk of providing information that could be misconstrued or used to strengthen the prosecution’s case​​​​.

2. Legal Strategy: Legal advisors often recommend a no comment interview to maintain a defensive position. This can be particularly effective if the evidence against you is weak or if the full extent of the allegations is unclear​​​​.

3. Control Over Information: By saying no comment, you control the flow of information. This can be beneficial in complex cases where the context of your answers could be misinterpreted​​.

• Adverse Inferences: Courts can draw adverse inferences from your silence under certain conditions, as outlined in Sections 34-37 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994. This means that the court may interpret your silence as an indication of guilt if you later present a defence in court that you did not mention during the interview​​​​.

• Perception: Public and judicial perception can be negatively influenced by a no comment response. Some may view it as an indication that you have something to hide​​.

Starting your interview with “no comment” is often a strategic move. Your solicitor might advise this if:

• The evidence against you is insufficient.
• The line of questioning is unclear or confusing.
• You risk implicating yourself or others in unrelated offences​​​​.

Legal Advice is Crucial

Before deciding to say no comment, it is essential to seek legal advice. A solicitor can assess the specifics of your case and provide tailored advice on whether this approach is suitable for you. They can also help you prepare for the interview, ensuring you understand the potential consequences of your responses​​​​.

Conclusion

Saying no comment in a police interview can be a powerful tool to protect your legal rights and avoid self-incrimination. However, it must be used judiciously and under the guidance of a legal professional to navigate its risks effectively. Always consult with a criminal defence solicitor to determine the best strategy for your situation.

FAQs

1. Why say no comment at a police interview? Saying no comment can help protect against self-incrimination and prevent providing evidence that could be used against you.

2. Can the court draw adverse inferences from a no comment interview? Yes, under certain conditions, the court may interpret your silence as an indication of guilt.

3. Is it always best to say no comment? Not always. The decision should be based on legal advice tailored to your specific case.

4. What are the legal grounds for saying no comment? The right to silence, protected under UK law, allows you to refrain from answering questions to avoid self-incrimination.

5. What are the risks of saying no comment? Potential adverse inferences by the court and negative public perception.

6. Should I consult a solicitor before saying no comment? Absolutely. Legal advice is crucial to understand the implications of this strategy.

7. Can saying no comment protect others? Yes, it can prevent implicating friends or family in unrelated offences.

8. What if the evidence against me is weak? Saying no comment can be a strategic move if the evidence is insufficient to charge you.

9. Does saying no comment affect the outcome of the case? It can, depending on how the court interprets your silence and the overall evidence.

10. Is saying no comment the same as remaining silent? Essentially, yes. Both are ways to exercise your right to silence during police questioning.

Summary and Conclusion

Understanding why to say no comment at a police interview can be crucial in protecting your rights and navigating the complexities of the legal system. While it offers protection against self-incrimination, it must be used carefully and under the guidance of a legal expert to avoid potential drawbacks such as adverse inferences and negative perceptions. Always seek legal advice to ensure this strategy aligns with your specific circ*mstances.

For more detailed information on handling police interviews and legal advice, visit JD Spicer Zeb Solicitors or Makwanas Solicitors.

URLs Used for Research:

• https://www.stuartmillersolicitors.co.uk
• https://www.jdspicer.co.uk
• https://www.makwanas.co.uk
• https://nechambers.co.uk
• https://www.oblaw.co.uk

Read our other prison pages such as Minimum prison sentence for Murder