Here’s a bold statement for you: the Yankees’ infield strategy this season is shaping up to be one of the most intriguing—and potentially controversial—moves in recent memory. But here's where it gets controversial... While the team is eyeing Ryan McMahon as a potential shortstop backup, his limited experience at the position raises eyebrows. Manager Aaron Boone has confirmed that McMahon will get some reps at short this spring, but let’s be clear: his professional experience at the position is a mere three innings with the 2020 Rockies. And this is the part most people miss... McMahon’s natural position is third base, where he’s an elite defender, ranking second in Defensive Runs Saved over the last three seasons. So, why the sudden shift? Well, with Anthony Volpe starting the season on the injured list following labrum surgery, the Yankees are left scrambling for infield depth. Utilityman José Caballero steps in as the primary shortstop, but the lack of a clear backup has the team exploring unconventional options.
Now, let’s talk about the elephant in the room: Amed Rosario. He’s the infielder with the most shortstop experience, having played the position daily earlier in his career with Cleveland. However, his defensive struggles have pushed him toward second and third base, and he’s only started 11 games at short since 2024. Here’s the kicker... While Rosario’s ability to hit left-handed pitching makes him a valuable bench player, his defensive limitations at short could be a liability. Other options like Max Schuemann and Oswaldo Cabrera can technically cover shortstop, but they’re better suited elsewhere. And then there’s Jorbit Vivas, who has never started a professional game at short—talk about a gamble.
So, why McMahon? Despite his lack of experience, he possesses the hands and arm strength to handle routine plays at short, even if his range might be stretched. But here’s the real question... Is McMahon a better fill-in than Rosario? If the Yankees believe so, it could allow them to use Caballero more strategically, pinch-hitting in key spots while ensuring better protection against injuries. This move would also enhance roster flexibility, potentially freeing up a spot for a player like Jasson Domínguez as a fourth outfielder.
Of course, this is all a temporary fix. The Yankees are hopeful Volpe will return early in the season, reclaiming his starting role and pushing Caballero back into his super utility position. Volpe, a 2023 Gold Glove winner, had a surprisingly poor defensive season last year, likely due to the shoulder injury he suffered in May. While his offensive numbers have been underwhelming—with a subpar batting average and on-base percentage—the team is banking on a healthy Volpe to bounce back and solidify the infield.
Here’s where it gets even more interesting... If the Yankees want a true shortstop off the bench, they might need to add a non-roster invitee like Braden Shewmake or Zack Short to the 40-man roster. But is that a risk worth taking? And what does this say about the team’s confidence in their current infield depth? These are the questions that have fans and analysts alike buzzing. What’s your take? Do you think McMahon can handle shortstop, or is this a recipe for disaster? Let’s hear it in the comments!
