Continuing Education Activity
Gaseous chlorine is poisonous and classified as a pulmonary irritant. It has intermediate water solubility with the capability of causing acute damage to the upper and lower respiratory tract. Most incidents of chlorine exposure are through accidental industrial or household exposures. Toxicity to chlorine gas depends on the dose and duration of exposure. Because of its strong odor, chlorine gas can be detected easily. Symptoms of chlorine gas exposure include burning of the conjunctiva, throat, and the bronchial tree. Higher concentrations can produce bronchospasm, lower pulmonary injury, and delayed pulmonary edema. This activity reviews the evaluation and treatment of chlorine gas toxicity and highlights the role of the interprofessional team in managing the patients affected by it.
Objectives:
Describe the pathophysiology of chlorine gas toxicity.
Summarize the epidemiology of chlorine gas toxicity.
Outline the typical presentation of a patient with chlorine gas toxicity.
Summarize the importance of improving care coordination among the interprofessional team to enhance the delivery of care for patients affected by chlorine gas toxicity.
Introduction
Gaseous chlorine is poisonous and classified as a pulmonary irritant. It has intermediate water solubility with the capability of causing acute damage to the upper and lower respiratory tract. Chlorine gas has many industrial uses, but it was also onceused as a chemical weapon in World War I. Today, most incidents of chlorine exposure are through accidental industrial or household exposures. As for industrial exposures, there have been several instances of train accidents carrying liquid chlorine that caused the release of chlorine gas to the surrounding environment. At home, a mixture of chlorine bleach with other household products that contain acid or ammonia is a common source of exposure to chlorine gas.
Toxicity to chlorine gas depends on the dose and duration of exposure. At concentrations of 1 to 3 ppm, chlorine gas acts as an eye and oral mucous membrane irritant; at 15 ppm, there is an onset of pulmonary symptoms, and it can be fatal at 430 ppm within 30 minutes.[1]
Because of its strong odor, chlorine gas can be detected easily. Symptoms of chlorine gas exposure include burning of the conjunctiva, throat, and the bronchial tree. Higher concentrations can produce bronchospasm, lower pulmonary injury, and delayed pulmonary edema.
Etiology
Chlorine gascan be used as a disinfecting agent at swimming pools, or it could form by mixing household agents. The combination of bleach (sodium hypochlorite) with acid produces chlorine gas, a heavy green-yellow gas with a strong odor. Chlorine gas has also been used asan industrial solvent and has other industrial uses such as the production of bulk materials, bleached paper products, plastics such as PVC, and solvents. Chlorine gas is also used to make dyes, textiles, paint, and even medications.
Chlorine gas is pressurized and cooled for easy storage in liquid form. When released, the liquid form of chlorine quickly turns into yellow-green colored gas with an irritating odor. Since chlorine is heavier than air, it accumulates in low-lying areas.
Chlorine gas has been used as an agent of war as recently as 2007 in Iraq.
Epidemiology
In 2016, theAmerican Association of Poison Control Centersreported over 6300 exposures to chlorine, making it the most common inhalational irritant in the United States.About 35%of exposures to chlorine gas were attributed to the mixing of household acid with hypochlorite.[2]
In addition to household exposure, there have been multiple episodes of incidents involving chlorine gas release.One of the worst was a 2007 collision of a railroad tanker carrying chlorine with another train causing rupture of the tank and release of 90 tons of chlorine gas into the surrounding area. Exposure to chlorine gas at the site of the accident resulted in 9 fatalities and 520 visits to local emergency departments in Graniteville, South Carolina.[3]
Chlorine gas is also the most frequent cause of major toxic release incidents internationally. Because of its widespread industrial use, chlorine gas has substantial potential for accidental release.
Besides household and industrial accidental exposures, chlorine gas has also been used as an agent of war. Germany used chlorine gas in World War I as a chemical weapon. More recently, in 2007, insurgents in Iraq executed multiple attacks by outfitting chlorine tankers with explosives and detonating them in multiple locations, causing hundreds of civilian casualties.
Pathophysiology
Chlorinewas thought to cause direct tissue damage by generating free oxygen species. However, more recent studies show that cellular injury may result from the oxidation of functional groups in cell components from the reaction of chlorine gas with tissue water. This reaction forms hypochlorous and hydrochloric acid along with free oxygen radicals.
Hypochlorous and hydrochloric acid cause most of the toxic effects attributed to chlorine gas. These acids are producedby the reaction of chlorine (Cl2) with water.[4]
Cl2+ H2O <--> HCl + HOCl <--> 2HCl + O-
Mild exposure may cause mucosal membrane irritation. More severe exposure will induce edema of both the upper airway and the lung parenchyma. Large acute exposure can induce wheezing, cough, and dyspnea. Acute lung injury and/or adult respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) can also beseen in somesevere cases. Chlorine gas is primarily reactive only at a local level, thus absorbed systemic effects are not commonly observed.[5][6]
Acids formed by the reaction of chlorine gas with water can react with the conjunctival mucous membrane, and although rare due to buffering by the tear film, can cause burns and corneal abrasions. These acid burns are generallysuperficial, only affecting the epithelial and basem*nt membrane.
Toxico*kinetics
Experimental studies using a low concentration of chlorine gas show that the upper airway absorbs the vast majority of inhaled chlorine. The lower respiratory tract absorbs only 5% of chlorine gas. Animal models suggest that chlorine gas absorbed in the lower respiratory tract causes much greater toxicity than similar amounts in the upper airway. Thus, the upper airway functions as a protective scrubber to the exposure of chlorine gas.
When exposed to low concentration chlorine gas (up to 2 ppm), mucous membrane irritation results. Higher concentration exposures between 9 ppm and 50 ppm may lead to chemical pneumonitis and bronchiolitis obliterans. In animal models, exposure to 200 ppm leads to extensive bronchial constriction. Exposure to levels of 800 ppm proves lethal to half of all exposed animals, while concentrations of 2000 ppm lead to immediate respiratory arrest.[4]
History and Physical
Symptoms of chlorine gas exposure are usually varied depending on the type ofexposure. For acute exposure at low levels (less than 5 ppm), patients can have lacrimation, nose and throat irritation, and excess salivation. Acute exposure at high levels causes dyspnea, violent cough, nausea, vomiting, lightheadedness, headache, chest pain, abdominal discomfort, and corneal burns, in addition to the same symptoms of low-level acute exposure. Chronic exposure to chlorine gas can lead to chest pain, cough, sore throat, and hemoptysis.
On physical exam, clinicians can discover respiratory findings such as tachypnea, cyanosis, wheezing, intercostal retractions, decreased breath sounds, rales, nasal flaring, stridor, hemorrhage of the respiratory tract, and rhinorrhea. Non-respiratory findings may include tachycardia, lacrimation, and salivation.[4]
Evaluation
Most patients should have pulse oximetry performed if possible. Mass casualty exposures may require triage of resources to those with more obvious symptoms. Acutely exposed patients with significant symptoms frequently will require a chest radiograph to determine the degree of lower respiratory tract involvement. Those with pronounced systemic symptoms (vomiting, altered mental status, acidosis, among others) will require laboratory evaluation which may include serum electrolytes, BUN and creatinine levels, arterial blood gas analysis, and electrocardiography. After stabilization, pulmonary function testing,ventilation-perfusiontesting, and laryngoscopy/bronchoscopy are occasionally usedto determine the extent of the injury.
Treatment / Management
Treatment of chlorine gas exposure is mostly supportive. Removal of the individual from the contaminated environmentis the first step of management. Clinicians will assess the patient’s airway, breathing, and circulation and provide humidified oxygen as necessary. Severe exposures may require endotracheal intubation. In cases of non-cardiogenic pulmonary edema, positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP), fluid restriction, and diuretics canbe used. Bronchospasm is treated with beta-agonists such as albuterol. The management of ocular exposure requires irrigation withcopious water or saline.
If irritation continues, clinicians should evaluate for corneal abrasion. Nebulized, 4% sodium bicarbonate may prove helpful as an adjunct treatment of chlorine gas exposure, although experience with this treatmentis limited. Research has not yet proven any benefit to corticosteroids nor the administration of systemic nitrites as a treatment for chlorine gas exposure.[7]
Differential Diagnosis
Most exposures to chlorine gas will present with a clear history of exposure obtained either from the patient themselves or first responders arriving from the scene. From prior exposures at chlorinated swimming pools, most patients will recognize the distinct odor of chlorine gas. Rarely a patient in respiratory distress and altered mental status may be foundafter the complete dispersal of chlorine gas, making the history unclear. Salivation, lacrimation, rhinorrhea, and bronchospasm can occur in cholinergic toxicityas well aschlorine gas exposure.
Prognosis
Chlorine gas exposure usually has a good prognosis, with most exposed individuals recovering without significant residual deficits. Pulmonary edema appears to be the most common cause of morbidity for moderate-to-severe exposures. This usually occurs within 2 to 4 hours of exposure to moderate chlorine concentration (25 to 50 ppm) or 30 to 60 minutes of severe exposure (greater than 50 ppm). Resolution of pulmonary abnormalities usually ensues a week to a month after exposure. Smokers and patients with asthma are likely to have persistent obstructive pulmonary defects.[8]
Studies on thelong-term adverse effects from acute chlorine exposure are inconclusive, with some studies showing decreased vital capacity, diffusing capacity, and total lung capacity and others showing no consistent pattern of pulmonary function deficits.[7][9]
Complications
Sloughing of the pulmonary mucosa can occur within 3 to 5 days in severe exposures leading to chemical pneumonitis that can often be complicated by secondary bacterial invasion and infection. Smoking and pre-existing respiratory conditions such as asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease appear to increase the risk of long-term complications such as pulmonary fibrosis.[10]
Deterrence and Patient Education
Attempts to reduce chlorine gas exposures focus on three strategies. First, improved transportation safety of a large volume of liquid chlorine, typically transported by rail. Second, development and adherence to strict industrial protocols for the use of chlorine to prevent inadvertent industrial exposure. Third, consumer education about the risk of mixing cleaning chemicals. Providers will need to educate patients exposed to chlorine gas in their homes. Failure to understand the risks of mixing certain solutions may lead to repeated exposures.
Pearls and Other Issues
Pulmonary or choking agents cause an inflammatory reaction when they come into direct contact with the eyes and upper airway. They can be life-threatening if inhaled. No specific antidote exists. Treatment is mainly supportive and consists of removal of the patient from the source, decontamination, airway maintenance, bronchodilator administration, and eye irrigation.
Enhancing Healthcare Team Outcomes
Chlorine gas poisoning is usually self-limited and mostly requires supportive treatment. Physicians and other health professionals, including nurses,EMS workers, and physician assistants, can play a vital role in educating the patient on the prevention of a future episode in household cases of accidental exposure resulting from mixing chlorine/bleach with other cleaning products. Although rare, if the poisoning was because of a suicide attempt, evaluation by a mental health professional should proceed discharge. An interprofessionalteam approach to decontamination and treatment is required for best patient outcomes. Specialty care nurses in emergency, prehospital, and flight are involved in triage, patient monitoring, and patient education. They monitor and provide updates to the team. Pharmacists review prescribed medication and drug-drug interactions. [Level V]
References
- 1.
Chauhan S, Chauhan S, D'Cruz R, Faruqi S, Singh KK, Varma S, Singh M, Karthik V. Chemical warfare agents. Environ Toxicol Pharmacol. 2008 Sep;26(2):113-22. [PubMed: 21783898]
- 2.
Gummin DD, Mowry JB, Spyker DA, Brooks DE, Fraser MO, Banner W. 2016 Annual Report of the American Association of Poison Control Centers' National Poison Data System (NPDS): 34th Annual Report. Clin Toxicol (Phila). 2017 Dec;55(10):1072-1252. [PubMed: 29185815]
- 3.
Wenck MA, Van Sickle D, Drociuk D, Belflower A, Youngblood C, Whisnant MD, Taylor R, Rudnick V, Gibson JJ. Rapid assessment of exposure to chlorine released from a train derailment and resulting health impact. Public Health Rep. 2007 Nov-Dec;122(6):784-92. [PMC free article: PMC1997246] [PubMed: 18051671]
- 4.
Das R, Blanc PD. Chlorine gas exposure and the lung: a review. Toxicol Ind Health. 1993 May-Jun;9(3):439-55. [PubMed: 8367885]
- 5.
White CW, Martin JG. Chlorine gas inhalation: human clinical evidence of toxicity and experience in animal models. Proc Am Thorac Soc. 2010 Jul;7(4):257-63. [PMC free article: PMC3136961] [PubMed: 20601629]
- 6.
Schwartz DA. Acute inhalational injury. Occup Med. 1987 Apr-Jun;2(2):297-318. [PubMed: 3303382]
- 7.
Vajner JE, Lung D. Case files of the University of California San Francisco Medical Toxicology Fellowship: acute chlorine gas inhalation and the utility of nebulized sodium bicarbonate. J Med Toxicol. 2013 Sep;9(3):259-65. [PMC free article: PMC3770993] [PubMed: 23719961]
- 8.
Brooks SM, Weiss MA, Bernstein IL. Reactive airways dysfunction syndrome (RADS). Persistent asthma syndrome after high level irritant exposures. Chest. 1985 Sep;88(3):376-84. [PubMed: 4028848]
- 9.
Francis HC, Prys-Picard CO, Fishwick D, Stenton C, Burge PS, Bradshaw LM, Ayres JG, Campbell SM, Niven RM. Defining and investigating occupational asthma: a consensus approach. Occup Environ Med. 2007 Jun;64(6):361-5. [PMC free article: PMC2078517] [PubMed: 17130175]
- 10.
Jones RN, Hughes JM, Glindmeyer H, Weill H. Lung function after acute chlorine exposure. Am Rev Respir Dis. 1986 Dec;134(6):1190-5. [PubMed: 3789518]
Disclosure: Ashkan Morim declares no relevant financial relationships with ineligible companies.
Disclosure: Gregory Guldner declares no relevant financial relationships with ineligible companies.
