Research
Nora Lustig Nora Lustig Nonresident Senior Fellow - Global Economy and Development
Nora Lustig Nora Lustig Nonresident Senior Fellow - Global Economy and Development
June 1, 1995
- 2 min read
Abstract
The financial debacle that followed the Mexican devaluation in December 1994 left many analysts, investors and observers bewildered by its magnitude. This paper argues that the causes of the devaluation are quite different from the causes of the crisis, so different that the financial crisis was partly caused by the devaluation itself. The devaluation was caused—primarily—by the fiscal and monetary policies followed during 1994. If the government’s primary concern was to maintain the existing exchange rate policy (i.e., avoid a discrete change in the exchange rate), both the fiscal and monetary policies were more expansionary than they should have been. But, why did the devaluation turn into a financial crisis? Contrary to what most analysts predicted, far from calming the markets the devaluation resulted in a financial crisis with significant spillover effects on other countries particularly in Latin America. The December devaluation triggered a financial crisis because foreign investors felt tricked and feared a default. Investors were angry for a very simple reason. The devaluation and its mishandling caused them substantial losses. Part of the investors’ disappointment arose from the perception, which turned out to be correct, that the fiscal and monetary policies pursued by the government in 1994 were ultimately inconsistent with the exchange rate rule. Another important contributing factor to the debacle of the peso was the replacement of almost the entire short-term government debt from peso-denominated to dollar-denominated instruments (the Tesobonos) because it vastly increased the risk of default. Finally, the lack of competence and the absence of a coherent plan at the time the devaluation was announced, added significantly to the climate of uncertainty.
Related Content
Latin America & the Caribbean China and Latin America: A pragmatic embrace Ted Piccone July 20, 2020
Latin America & the Caribbean Harold Trinkunas Named Senior Fellow and Director of the Foreign Policy at Brookings Latin America Initiative September 10, 2013
Latin America & the Caribbean Spatial and Temporal Patterns in Civil Violence: Guatemala 1977-1986 Timothy R. Gulden February 1, 2002
Related Books
Global Trade Coming Together? Barry P. Bosworth, Susan M. Collins, Nora Claudia Lustig May 1, 1997
U.S. Economy Declining Inequality in Latin America Luis Felipe López-Calva, Nora Claudia Lustig May 28, 2010
Latin America & the Caribbean Post-Stabilization Politics in Latin America Carol Wise, Riordan Roett July 28, 2003
Global Education How education fails young women in Mexico and what we can do about it Magdalena Rodríguez Romero September 10, 2024
Foreign Politics & Elections How would Harris shape US-Latin America relations? Vanda Felbab-Brown August 15, 2024
Mexico US-Mexico relations: Addressing challenges at the border University of Nevada, Las Vegas, Las Vegas Nevada 4:00 pm - 5:30 pm PDT