Vanilla slice recipe, Leila McKinnon (2024)

Recipe for vanilla slice by Leila McKinnon.

Oct 16, 2012 3:20am

By Leila McKinnon

  • Serves 8
  • Vanilla slice recipe, Leila McKinnon (1)

    Print

Searching for recipes to add to her kitchen repertoire, Leila McKinnon discovered a treasure trove - and published it.

Australia's restaurants, chefs and produce are acknowledged as among the best in the world. Our baristas have taken over Europe, flat white by long black. But it's what's going on in our suburban kitchens that deserves the wildest of nationalistic chest thumping.

I should know: I've stuck my nose into hundreds of handwritten recipe books in the past year, sniffing out old gems and modern classics like a Tasmanian truffle pig. And best of all, I've begged permission to publish them in the unlikeliest of places: a cookbook edited by me, a news journalist, and ordained by our greatest food revolutionary, Margaret Fulton.

Australia's Favourite Recipes started out as a way for me to get my unimaginative hands on some good, honest everyday recipes for home. I was never short of a dinner party recipe, but what I needed were dishes I could cook on a weeknight with ingredients I could buy from the corner shop, dishes that took less than 30 minutes to make, and treats that one day my kids would come home for and be transported back to their childhoods. I wanted the dishes families have made and enjoyed week after week, often for generations, and never tired of.

We did a shout-out on the Today show, we asked for recipes on radio and called for submissions on Facebook. In the end we received several hundred and had to whittle them down to just over 70. They came in spidery handwriting by mail, in shouty capitals on Facebook, and with photos of grandpas, nonnas, hungry kids, and proud home cooks. And with a few notable exceptions (ham cooked in instant coffee, anyone? Schnitzel with banana-avocado sauce?) they were fresh, inspired and nourishing.

There were plenty of lovingly perfected lasagnes and lamingtons, but also some outstanding exotics. Steve Wide's jewelled freekeh salad mixes pomegranate and hearty lentils with mint, almonds and currants; it's an absolute delight. There were Italian dishes from nonna, and noodles from the Philippines. There were stories of lunch-box treats (chocolate Weet-Bix slice from Margaret of Mollymook) and of a boyfriend brought home to meet mum over a zesty lime and chocolate green pudding. I threw in a few of my all-time best fallbacks including vanilla slice, my lasagne (yes, I do think my version is the best - doesn't everyone think that about their own?), and a lemon yoghurt cake that's one of the quickest, most fuss-free cake recipes around.

Armed with this plunder, I went about the dream task of putting together a recipe book. The team and I set up camp in a cottage in country Victoria in the depths of winter. Detouring around flooded roads, well prepared with wellies and beanies, we began a cooking, photographing and eating marathon.

The process was quite a revelation for this novice food editor. By day two I found myself sounding like a real pro with proclamations such as, "We're going to have to swap that hero mussel for a hero prawn, and move that white pepper pot more to the right of frame" or, "Ahem, we need fresher herbs on the salmon - those baked herbs look like they'd set the sniffer dogs barking at a music festival."

By day five we were running out of patience, vintage tea towels, and holes with which to loosen our belts. But we'd put together a snap­shot of 21st-century Australian home dining.

It's only fitting that a community-based true-blue charity should benefit from this treasure trove, so I approached Legacy with an offer of a large portion of the profits. Since World War I, Legacy's incredible volunteers have been helping the families of our deceased and incapacitated servicemen and women, and unfortunately their work has been needed by every successive generation.

The cover recipe - the icing on the cake, if you like - is a Margaret Fulton berry-meringue creation, a cross between a good old pavlova and a vacherin. It's as exciting as Fulton's forthright assertion that "this is a book to treasure and keep".

Goodness me, it will be a long time before I clamber down from cloud nine, and even then I'll still have a lifetime of reliable, delicious family recipes at my fingertips.

Ingredients

  • 2 sheets shop-bought puff pastry
  • 2 cups milk (500ml)
  • Scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean
  • 100 gm cornflour
  • ½ cup caster sugar
  • 4 egg yolks, at room temperature
  • For dusting: sieved icing sugar

Method

Main

  • 1

    Preheat the oven to 210C and line two oven trays with baking paper.

  • 2

    Place the sheets of puff pastry on the prepared trays and bake until crisp and golden. Remove from the oven and set aside to cool.

  • 3

    Heat the milk and vanilla seeds in a small saucepan over medium heat and bring to the boil, then remove from the heat.

  • 4

    Place the cornflour and sugar in a heatproof bowl. Add the egg yolks and whisk until pale and creamy. Add one-third of the hot milk and stir to combine, then add the remaining hot milk and stir to combine.

  • 5

    Return the mixture to the pan over low heat and bring to a gentle boil, then transfer to a bowl and leave to cool completely.

  • 6

    Line a 25cm x 12cm straight-sided cake tin with enough plastic wrap so that it hangs over the sides. Trim the pastry sheets to fit the tin. Place one pastry sheet in the base of the tin, add the custard and evenly spread. Top with the remaining pastry sheet and refrigerate until the custard is set, ideally overnight.

  • 7

    Remove from the tin using the plastic wrap as handles, generously dust with icing sugar and cut into 6-8 slices.

Notes

Note "Vanilla slice takes me straight back in time to the school tuckshop. Back then, I didn't appreciate the time and skill that went into making these delicious treats. The trickiest part of this recipe is making sure the custard sets perfectly. My first couple of batches turned out a bit sloppy but I didn't let them go to waste - they were still delicious and I just ate them with a spoon. If your first attempt doesn't set right, don't be disheartened - it will still taste good. Keep trying until you get the ideal set."Australia's Favourite Recipes, edited by Leila McKinnon, is published by Plum Pan Macmillan ($29.99, pbk). The recipe here has been reproduced with minor GT style changes.

The Latest from Gourmet Traveller

  • Travel NewsOur top picks of hotels with the best views of Vivid Sydney 2024

    Yesterday 1:00pm

  • CruisesItaly by Sea: On board the revamped luxury ship Crystal Serenity

    Yesterday 5:00am

  • EntertainingBest whisky glasses to buy for sophisticated dram sipping

    Yesterday 3:00am

  • Restaurant NewsComing soon: Ormeggio team to open new restaurant Postino Osteria in Sydney’s Summer Hill

    Mar 13, 2024

  • Recipe CollectionsEaster desserts that aren't hot cross buns

    Mar 11, 2024

  • Recipe CollectionsRabbit recipes for Easter

    Mar 11, 2024

  • Recipe CollectionsAll the Easter recipes you need

    Mar 11, 2024

  • Vivid Sydney’s food program is back for 2024

    Mar 10, 2024

  • Travel NewsVirgin Australia is offering 30% off flights to 36 destinations in flash sale

    Mar 10, 2024

  • DestinationsBeyond laneways: A peek into some of Melbourne's most luxe Airbnb stays

    Mar 10, 2024

  • EntertainingGozney's new Arc pizza oven here to heat up the alfresco entertaining game?

    Mar 07, 2024

  • This is how women do it: Leading women in restaurants

    Mar 07, 2024

  • Drinks NewsTop drops: An expert's best tannic wines for March

    Mar 07, 2024

  • Travel NewsTurkish Airlines announces direct flights between Melbourne and Istanbul from March 2024

    Mar 06, 2024

  • EntertainingYour seasonal guide to luxury Easter eggs, bunnies and hampers

    Mar 05, 2024

  • Food NewsNoma returns to Japan for 10-week Noma Kyoto residency in 2024

    Mar 05, 2024

  • Restaurant NewsNoma, the 'world's best restaurant', is closing in 2025

    Mar 05, 2024

  • Restaurant ReviewsPipis Kiosk: Restaurant review

    Mar 05, 2024

  • Recipe CollectionsOur most popular recipes for autumn

    Mar 05, 2024

Vanilla slice recipe, Leila McKinnon (2024)

FAQs

Who makes the best vanilla slice? ›

With a record number of entries from over 130 bakeries in Victoria, South Australia and New South Wales, Matt Aylett of North End Bakehouse in Shepparton won two major awards: Australia's Best Hot Cross Bun and Australia's Best Vanilla Slice.

What is the difference between a vanilla slice and a French vanilla slice? ›

The main difference between vanilla and French vanilla is the addition of egg yolks and the custardization process.

What is the difference between a vanilla slice and a bavarian slice? ›

However, the Bavarian Slice is a little more indulgent, and dare I say posher, than the slightly plainer custard slice with its layer of jam sat snugly beneath a creamier filling. The icing is also usually finished with the classic feathering pattern too.

What is the best way to cut a vanilla slice? ›

My Top Tips!
  1. When slicing the vanilla slice, make sure you do it slowly. Gently score the pastry with a serrated knife. Then make the full slice in one go.
  2. Dust with powdered sugar after the vanilla slices have been cut. I just feel it results in a much nicer looking and neater vanilla slice.
Aug 7, 2021

Who won the vanilla slice in 2024? ›

Baker Matt Aylett from North End Bakehouse in Shepparton claimed the two major awards at the Baking Association of Australia's (BAA) Baking Show last weekend — winning Australia's best hot cross bun for a third time and best vanilla slice for a second. “The little bakery that could!” the bakery wrote on social media.

What kind of vanilla do bakeries use? ›

Vanilla beans, paste, and extracts have more depth of flavor than imitation vanilla, but many of those flavor notes break down at the high temperatures used during baking. For this reason, imitation vanilla is preferred by some bakers for cookies and cakes.

What is a good alternative to lattice biscuits for vanilla slices? ›

Tip: If you're missing Lattice biscuits (like us), then turn to SAO biscuits or Julie's Sugar Crackers. They're a great alternative!

What pastry are vanilla slices made from? ›

Vanilla slice is an Australian pastry comprising a thick layer of vanilla custard sandwiched between puff pastry and topped with icing sugar or thinly iced.

What is another name for a vanilla slice? ›

A mille-feuille (French: [mil fœj]; lit. 'thousand-sheets'), also known by the names Napoleon in North America, vanilla slice in the United Kingdom, and custard slice, is a French dessert made of puff pastry layered with pastry cream.

Why is it called a snot block? ›

A rose by any other name

Replacing the plain English name (vanilla slice, custard block) with an irreverent and outrageous moniker (“snot block” or “phlegm sandwich”) is standard practice in Australia, where informality and a lack of pretence are hallmarks of the vernacular.

What nationality is vanilla slice? ›

Imported from Europe, the vanilla slice has been fully assimilated into Australian food culture, an identifiable icon. A sure measure of its acceptance as a genuine element of Aussie culture is its unpretentious alias – snot block. You know you really belong when you finally get a nickname.

Is a mille feuille the same as a vanilla slice? ›

A vanilla slice is usually a very thick slab of custard sandwiched between two thin puff sheets. A mille feuille is more decorative, could have multiple custard (or diplomat cream) layers and looks very sophisticated. It is one of the simplest things you can make with a puff sheet, yet looks so elegant!

Which bakery won the best vanilla slice? ›

North End Bakehouse crowned best vanilla slice, best hot cross bun in Australia. A regional bakery has claimed bragging rights as the makers of the best vanilla slice and hot cross bun in Australia.

How are you supposed to eat vanilla slices? ›

However the “right way” involved turning the dessert on its side before taking to it with a knife, ensuring the vanilla slice remains intact. Social media users were stunned by the revelation, but many joked they'd never thought about cutting the dessert before. “Why are you cutting a vanilla slice?

Does vanilla slice need to be refrigerated? ›

Custard slice or vanilla slice is best eaten the day it's made because the custard will soften the puff pastry quickly. However, you can keep vanilla slice for 3-4 days in an airtight container in the fridge.

Who makes the best vanilla in the world? ›

Although it is not native to the country, vanilla produced in Madagascar is considered the gold standard. Vanilla grown outside of its native Mexico must be pollinated completely by hand during a five- to six-hour window of blooming. Once pollinated, beans take about three to four months to mature.

What is the highest grade of vanilla? ›

Grade A Vanilla Beans are considered the best. They are primarily grown in Peru and Madagascar, but also in other parts of South America, Africa and India. The beans are harvested when they're just right—not too ripe or too green. Grade B Vanilla Beans are less expensive than Grade A beans—but you get what you pay for.

Is Taylor and Colledge vanilla extract good? ›

Perfect for home made and professional bakes, this rich, vanilla extract is ideal for flavouring custards, puddings and sponges. Taylor & Colledge is committed to providing unsurpassed quality throughout its products and has earned its reputation as one of the world's finest vanilla producers.

What vanilla do pastry chefs use? ›

Chef's notes: Tahitian Pure Vanilla is a favorite of pastry chefs. Chefs recommend using it only in dishes that will not be exposed to high heat, in order to retain its delicate flavor.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Errol Quitzon

Last Updated:

Views: 5763

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Errol Quitzon

Birthday: 1993-04-02

Address: 70604 Haley Lane, Port Weldonside, TN 99233-0942

Phone: +9665282866296

Job: Product Retail Agent

Hobby: Computer programming, Horseback riding, Hooping, Dance, Ice skating, Backpacking, Rafting

Introduction: My name is Errol Quitzon, I am a fair, cute, fancy, clean, attractive, sparkling, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.